Two days later, on 4 February 1889, a special meeting of the
Scottish Football Association was held to discuss the match. Both teams claimed that prior to the match they had agreed that because of the poor playing conditions it would be played as a friendly. Although a signed document was produced to show that the teams had agreed to play the match as a friendly, it was challenged by some members.
Airdrieonians representative Mr Reid moved that the agreement should not be recognised and the result should stand. The referee,
Charles Campbell, and his umpires were then questioned and stated that the ground had been unplayable. Following this admission it was unanimously agreed that the tie be replayed the following Saturday. ==Replay==