Alumni qualified for the final after having won the
Copa de Competencia Jockey Club, where the squad beat Rosarian teams
Provincial (4–0) and
Rosario Central (3–1 in
Colegiales),
San Isidro (3–2) and
Newell's Old Boys in the final (5–1). The match was held in
Gimnasia y Esgrima Stadium in
Palermo on 5 September 1905. There was a low attendance due to bad weather. The rain fallen during almost all the morning prior to the match left the field so muddy that players had problems to control the ball. Even though,
Eliseo Brown received the ball 40 meters from the rival goal and started his run. When he was 25 meters from the goal Brown shot for the first goal of Alumni. On 40 minutes, Weiss passed to
Arnold Watson Hutton who shot to the goal. Goalkeeper Pintos stopped the shot but the ball rebounded on his hands so
Alfredo Brown took advantage of the play to score the second goal. Three minutes later, another pass from Weiss was connected by Eliseo Brown who scored the third goal. The fourth goal came in the second half, with few minutes left when Eliseo Brown scored the last one for the final 4–0 of Alumni over CURCC. He was also the topscorer of the match with three goals. This edition of the Tie Cup was the last international title won by Alumni. In 1911 the club ceased its participation in official football competitions and two year later it was definitively dissolved. == Match details ==