Quarterbacks •
Y. A. Tittle, San Francisco 49ers (AP) •
Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts (AP-2)
Halfbacks •
Frank Gifford, New York Giants (AP) •
Ollie Matson, Chicago Cardinals (AP) •
Hugh McElhenny, San Francisco 49ers (AP-2) •
Tommy Wilson, Los Angeles Rams (AP-2)
Fullbacks •
Jim Brown, Cleveland Browns (AP) •
Rick Casares, Chicago Bears (AP-2)
Ends •
Billy Wilson, San Francisco 49ers (AP) •
Billy Howton, Green Bay Packers (AP) •
Raymond Berry, Baltimore Colts (AP-2) •
Darrel Brewster, Cleveland Browns (AP-2)
Tackles •
Lou Creekmur, Detroit Lions (AP) •
Rosey Brown, New York Giants (AP) •
Lou Groza, Cleveland Browns (AP-2) •
Mike McCormack, Cleveland Browns (AP-2)
Guards •
Duane Putnam, Los Angeles Rams (AP) •
Dick Stanfel, Washington Redskins (AP) •
Harley Sewell, Detroit Lions (AP-2) •
Jack Stroud, New York Giants (AP-2)
Centers •
Jim Ringo, Green Bay Packers (AP) •
Larry Strickland, Chicago Bears (AP-2) ==Defensive selections==