Plante made his debut as a Ranger on October 9 against
Chicago, losing 3–1 and being cut by an elbow from Black Hawk
Johnny McKenzie. He fared no better four nights later in the home opener in Montreal against the Canadiens, losing 6–2 in the
Forum while the fans both applauded and jeered their former goaltender. While Mikita signed his contract in time for the start of the season, star defenceman
Carl Brewer of the Maple Leafs was a holdout and claimed he was going to retire from hockey to attend the
University of Toronto; contract terms were agreed upon by the end of October. Montreal defeated the Red Wings 6–4 in Detroit, but the highlight of the game was
Gordie Howe scoring his 544th goal to tie Maurice Richard's all-time career goal scoring mark and he drew a five-minute ovation from the capacity crowd. Toronto defeated Montreal 6–3 at
Maple Leaf Gardens on October 30 in a penalty-filled game; the most prominent fight featured Canadien
Terry Harper and Maple Leaf
Bob Pulford who drew fighting majors. There were two lasting consequences; Canadien goaltender
Gump Worsley badly pulled his
hamstring in the match and was eventually replaced by
Charlie Hodge for the remainder of the season. Furthermore, on November 8, Maple Leaf Gardens became the first arena in the NHL to have separate penalty boxes installed. The first penalty shot of the season was taken on November 3, with the Canadiens defeating the Rangers 5–3 in
Madison Square Garden.
Don Marshall, having been tripped by
Jean Beliveau of Montreal, took the shot, but Canadien goaltender Charlie Hodge made the save. Nonetheless, the Rangers' management was not happy with the officiating of referee Vern Buffey, and called for the removal of referee-in-chief
Carl Voss, a demand rejected by league president
Clarence Campbell. Detroit defeated the Canadiens 3–0 on November 10. Famously, two longtime career records were set in this match.
Gordie Howe scored a shorthanded goal on
Charlie Hodge for his 545th career goal, breaking
Maurice Richard's record. Further, Detroit netminder
Terry Sawchuk recorded his 94th career NHL shutout, tying him with
George Hainsworth as the all-time NHL shutout leader. Howe would hold the all-time career goalscoring record for thirty seasons until broken by
Wayne Gretzky in 1994, while Sawchuk would hold the all-time shutout record for forty-five seasons, when it was broken in 2009 by
Martin Brodeur. By late November it was clear to Ranger management that Doug Harvey had lost his form entirely and was given his release. He finished out the season in the AHL with the
Quebec Aces. Another career milestone fell on December 4, when
Andy Hebenton of the Bruins broke the all-time career iron man streak, playing in his 581st consecutive game, to surpass
Johnny Wilson's mark. He would extend the streak to 630 games, his last in the NHL, while continuing his career in the minors, where he would play ten more straight seasons without missing a match. An unusual record fell on December 12, in a Montreal–New York match won 6–4 by the Canadiens.
Dave Balon and
Gilles Tremblay of Montreal and
Camille Henry of the Rangers scored goals within a frame of eighteen seconds, setting a mark for the fastest three goals by two teams. In a game on December 22 when Montreal exploded for five goals in nine minutes of the second period in a 6–1 win against Detroit, Canadien
Jean Beliveau scored a goal to make him the highest scoring center in league history. Rookie Detroit goaltender
Roger Crozier, substituting for injured Terry Sawchuk, recorded his second shutout against Boston on January 7. Only 7,000 fans attended in
Boston Garden to see the last place Bruins play, chanting "
We shall overcome" to register their opinion on their team's performance. On January 18,
Terry Sawchuk broke
George Hainsworth's NHL career shutout record with his 95th in a 2–0 win over Montreal. That same night, cellar dwelling Boston staggered the Maple Leafs 11–0 in Toronto,
Andy Hebenton and
Dean Prentice each scoring hat tricks. On February 1, Montreal forward
Bobby Rousseau scored five goals against Detroit in a 9–3 whipping of the Red Wings, one behind the league record for a single game and the first time five goals had been scored by a player in a single match in nearly a decade. A trade rumored most of the season finally took place on February 22 when the New York Rangers traded
Andy Bathgate – whom the Maple Leafs had coveted for some time – and
Don McKenney to Toronto in exchange for
Dick Duff,
Bob Nevin,
Arnie Brown,
Bill Collins and
Rod Seiling. Ranger fans did not like the deal and in the next game chants of "Muzz must go!" were heard, referring to
Muzz Patrick, the Rangers' general manager. However, Bathgate – his days as a scoring star through – and McKenney both would be gone from Toronto by the end of the next season, while Seiling, Nevin and Brown would star for the Rangers for many years to come. Several players scored their 200th goal in the season, with
Camille Henry of the Rangers scoring his against Boston on October 20,
Bobby Hull of the Black Hawks against the Rangers on December 11, Dean Prentice of the Bruins against the Hawks on December 12, as well as
George Armstrong and Frank Mahovlich. Goaltender
Eddie Johnston played every minute of all 70 games for the Boston Bruins, the last time in NHL history a goaltender played every minute of every game. The regular season title was secured by the Canadiens after Chicago, which had a substantial lead halfway through the season, played little better than .500 hockey the rest of the way; a Habs' 2–1 win against the Rangers on the road the last game of the season was needed to nose ahead of the Black Hawks, which had never to that date finished first in the league standings.
Final standings ==Playoffs==