The official selection order was set by
Major League Soccer on October 21, 2011: • 2012 expansion team
Montreal Impact had the first selection; • The eight clubs which did not qualify for the playoffs received picks #2 through #9 (in reverse order of season points); • The two clubs eliminated in the Wild Card round of playoffs received picks #10 and #11 (in reverse order of season points); • The four clubs eliminated in the Conference Semifinals received picks #12 through #15 (in reverse order of season points); • The two clubs eliminated in the Conference Finals received picks #16 and #17 (in reverse order of season points); • The club which lost the
2011 MLS Cup received pick #18; • The club which won the
2011 MLS Cup received pick #19. This selection order held for all four rounds of the Supplemental Draft.
Round 1 Round 1 Trades Round 2 Round 2 Trades Round 3 Round 3 Trades Round 4 Round 4 Trades == Note on SuperDraft Trades ==