Cleveland vs. New York
This was the fourth postseason meeting between the Indians and Yankees, with Cleveland winning two of the three previous series including both times in the ALDS (
1997 and
2007). The Yankees won the
1998 ALCS.
Game 1 Cy Young Award candidate
Corey Kluber was not tapped for this start to give him full rest. Thus, the Indians started
Trevor Bauer, who befuddled the Yankees. He was followed by strong bullpen innings by
Andrew Miller and
Cody Allen, resulting in only the fourth shutout the Yankees experienced all season. The Indians loaded the bases on a double, single, and walk with no outs off
Sonny Gray in the second inning, but scored just one run on
Roberto Pérez's double play.
Jay Bruce's two-run
home run in the fourth after a walk extended the Indians' lead to 3–0. After getting out of a bases-loaded one-out jam that inning,
Adam Warren allowed a leadoff single in the fifth to
José Ramírez, who moved to third on two wild pitches before scoring on Bruce's sacrifice fly off
Jaime García for the game's final run as the Indians took a 1–0 series lead with a 4–0 win.
Game 2 Former Indians
ace CC Sabathia faced off against current Indians ace
Corey Kluber. Kluber lasted just innings, giving up a season-high six
runs.
Gary Sánchez's two-run home run after a walk in the first put the Yankees up 2–0, but the Indians loaded the bases with one out on an error, walk, and hit-by-pitch before
Carlos Santana tied the game with a two-run single. The Indians again loaded the bases in the second on a single, error, and intentional walk when
Jason Kipnis's RBI single put the Indians up 3–2. In the third, Sánchez singled with one out, moved to second on a groundout, and scored on
Starlin Castro's single to tie the game. After a
Greg Bird single,
Aaron Hicks's three-run home run put the Yankees up 6–3, chasing Kluber. Bird's two-run home run after a walk off
Mike Clevinger extended the Yankees' lead to 8–3, but in the sixth, Sabathia was pulled by
manager Joe Girardi with one on and one out. Later with two on and two outs, controversy occurred when
relief pitcher Chad Green was charged with a
hit by pitch on
Lonnie Chisenhall to load the bases. Replays showed the ball to have hit the knob of the
bat, which would have resulted in a
strikeout on the
foul tip to end the
inning. Despite Yankees'
catcher Gary Sánchez insisting that Girardi challenge it, Girardi decided not to do so, extending the inning. Two
pitches later,
Francisco Lindor hit a
grand slam to bring the Indians within one. They tied the game in the bottom of the eighth on a
home run by
Jay Bruce off
David Robertson before winning it in the 13th when
Austin Jackson walked off
Dellin Betances, stole second and scored on a walk-off single off the bat of
Yan Gomes. This was Cleveland’s final playoff win under the Indians moniker, as they were swept in 2018 and 2020 before changing names to the Guardians.
Game 3 With their season on the line, the Yankees started
Masahiro Tanaka for Game three against the Indians'
Carlos Carrasco. Tanaka pitched brilliantly, confusing Indians hitters for seven shutout innings with his splitter. Yankees right fielder
Aaron Judge robbed
Francisco Lindor of a two-run
home run in the top of the sixth to preserve the scoreless tie. Yankees
first baseman Greg Bird scored the game's only run on a home run off former Yankee
reliever Andrew Miller in the seventh inning. The Indians threatened to score in the eighth and ninth innings, but relievers
David Robertson and
Aroldis Chapman managed to preserve the shutout and keep the Yankees' season alive.
Game 4 After lasting only innings against the
Minnesota Twins in the
2017 American League Wild Card Game, Yankees pitcher
Luis Severino bounced back with seven strong innings. The Indians gave up seven runs on the night, but just one
earned, as the Yankees took advantage of the Indians' four
errors on the night. In the second,
Starlin Castro reached on an error and moved to second on
Roberto Perez's passed ball before
Todd Frazier's double and
Aaron Hicks's single scored a run each. After
Brett Gardner singled and stole second,
Aaron Judge's two-run double made it 4–0 Yankees. An errant throw on Gardner's ground ball with the bases loaded next inning off
Mike Clevinger made it 5-0 Yankees. The Indians made it 5–2 on a two-run home run by
Carlos Santana in the fourth and 5-3 after a home run by
Roberto Pérez in the fifth. In the bottom of the fifth, Frazier reached second on an error off
Danny Salazar, moved to third on a ground out, and scored on a
Brett Gardner sacrifice fly off
Tyler Olson. Next inning, a home run from Sánchez off
Bryan Shaw, the only earned run the Yankees scored, put them up by four runs again.
Reliever Tommy Kahnle earned the save for a tired
bullpen as the Yankees tied up the series and forced a decisive fifth game in
Cleveland.
Game 5 The series returned to
Cleveland for the fifth and decisive final game. Yankees
shortstop Didi Gregorius hit
home runs in back-to-back
at bats in the first and third innings (two-run home run) to give the Yankees a 3–0 lead. The Indians sliced into the lead with four straight one-out singles, the last two by
Roberto Pérez and
Giovanny Urshela, in the bottom of the fifth, chasing Yankee
starter CC Sabathia. In the top of the ninth with closer
Cody Allen on the
mound, the Yankees got runners on by a base hit by
Aaron Hicks, who advanced to second on an
error by
Austin Jackson. A
walk by
Todd Frazier brought
Brett Gardner to the plate with two on and two out. After a 12-pitch
at bat, Gardner hit an
RBI single scoring Hicks. Frazier then scored when
Jay Bruce's throw bounced away from
Francisco Lindor to make it 5–2.
Aroldis Chapman pitched a two-inning
save for his second save of the series. The Yankees clinched the ALDS when Chapman struck out Jackson, and completed the series comeback, becoming just the seventh team to come back from a 2–0 deficit in a
division series since the wild-card format was introduced in
1995. The Yankees previously accomplished this feat in
2001 against the
Oakland Athletics. They are also just the second team to do it twice in the Division Series after the
Boston Red Sox, who accomplished this in
1999 (also against the
Indians) and
2003 (also against the
Athletics).
Composite line score 2017 ALDS (3–2):
New York Yankees defeated
Cleveland Indians. ==Houston vs. Boston==