After the team had been relegated to the second division they returned to the top division. This happened after winning the second division and K/O Championships in the 1961-62 season. Another match in which the Xagħra Young Stars honored themselves as well as their village was the one played with the Floriana Football Club on Sunday, December 30, 1962. As the winners of the Gozo second division championship and Floriana championships of Malta, a
friendly match was played where the team from Xagħra lost with the score of 1–0 after a stupendous display and a strong opposition against an excellent team. The 1963–1964 season saw the Xagħra Young Stars return to glory when the Gozo Championships were held for the second time in their history after a quarter of a century of competitive games in Gozo. The match was against
Victoria Hotspurs and in it Xagħra won with a score of 2–1. An interesting fact was that the game was a replay after the first one was won by Victoria Hotspurs but due to the fact that there was only one linesman it was played again after a protest. Another success of the Young Stars team towards the end of their work was with winning the "British-American Shield" in the 1968–1969 season. Towards the end of the '60s, the village of Xagħra saw the establishment of another football team called "Xagħra Blue Stars." The location of the club of this new team was where it is to this day, in Triq l-Arċipriet Dun Ġużeppi Diacono. Despite their efforts, the two Xagħra teams did not start to show much positive results so much so that in 1971, the two teams came together. A clear example of this is the current name of the Xagħra team, "Xagħra United F.C." The club of the new team remained that of Triq l-Arċipriet Dun Ġużeppi Diacono. The Xagħra team under the new name immediately started with its successes when it was promoted to the top division. In the same season the team won the Knock-Out cup of the same division and the Good Conduct Cup. The years 1972 and 1973 brought with them the success of the ESSO Cup, a competition that was won only once by the Xagħra team in the last year it was played. ==1970s & 1980s==