for whom the theatre was originally named In 1906 the theatrical entrepreneur
Lee Shubert had presented
Alla Nazimova in matinee performances of three
Ibsen plays and was reportedly "bewitched" by the beautiful Russian actress. Hoping to become a major producer of serious drama in New York and to continue promoting Nazimova, he built a new theatre on 39th Street and Broadway which he named Nazimova's 39th Street Theatre. After a two-week delay from the announced date of April 4, 1910, the theatre finally opened on April 18 with Nazimova starring as Rita Allmers in Ibsen's
Little Eyolf. While her acting was praised by the critics, the play was not.
The New York Times, pronounced it "peculiar" and
The Evening Post termed it "dreary, unprofitable, and obnoxious." Nazimova's business relationship with the theatre and Shubert was short-lived. By February 1911, she had signed with
Charles Frohman instead. According to
The Morning Telegraph, Shubert had offered her a guaranteed weekly salary of $1,500 and a 50% share of the profits as an inducement to remain with his organization, but to no avail. When Nazimova signed with Frohman, Shubert immediately removed her name from the theatre, and it was known as simply the 39th Street Theatre for the remainder of its existence. Despite its parting of the ways with Nazimova, the 39th Street Theatre became a popular theatrical landmark. According to
The New York Times, it was
Diamond Jim Brady's favorite playhouse. Among the plays presented there were
The Second Mrs. Tanqueray starring
Mrs. Leslie Carter;
A. E. W. Mason's
Green Stockings. starring
Margaret Anglin; and
Believe Me, Xantippe starring
John Barrymore,
Mary Young, and
Douglas Fairbanks. One of its longest-running plays was
Cosmo Hamilton's
Scandal which ran for thirty-nine weeks. The shortest was
A Little Bit of Fluff. According to
The New York Times, it opened and closed on the same night in August 1916. In May 1925 the Shubert Organization sold the theatre to
A. E. Lefcourt, a real estate developer who was to erect a 20-story building with offices and showrooms on the site. The 39th Street Theatre was demolished in December of that year. During its existence, it had seen over 21,600 performances. ==Architecture==