"5 By 5" was well received by critics, but although the record followed several hit singles and the Dave Clark Five simultaneously released a new hit "Live in the Sky", the LP did not enter the UK charts (which were only published as Top 20 at the time).
Melody Maker wrote in the official review, "Well-produced and highly commercial album which will sell." And highlighted the quality of singer Mike Smith. Allen Evans from
New Musical Express wrote, "All the tracks have that organ-drums-guitar crisp sound and the vocals, by various members but mostly Mike Smith on solos. ... A happy piece of pop, as always from producer Dave Clark."
Record Mirror highlighted several points, "First, that there is a tremendous sense of ambitiousness in the way Dave is producing his own records now. Second, that there is definitely a sudden upsurge in the boys' popularity at all levels now. Third, that Mike Smith is still one of the most interestingly exciting singers in the business."
Disc and Music Echo wrote, "The album will please their fans, it won't exactly blow the minds of the unbiased". ==Track listing==