A Closed and Common Orbit was a finalist for the 2017
Hugo Award for Best Novel. At
The Guardian,
Adam Roberts noted that, although the novel is a sequel, it "works as a standalone story"; he also observed that it shares the first book's strengths (including "complex characters" and "sheer likability") and weaknesses (including "a tendency for characters to pootle about rather than move the larger plot forward").
Publishers Weekly called it "worthy", with a "friendly, soothing atmosphere" and "beautiful pacing and structure".
Strange Horizons lauded Chambers both for her "delightful
world-building", and for her skillful presentation thereof.
The A.V. Club considered it to be "more intimate than its predecessor", while
James Nicoll described it as "more focused (and) more effective". ==References==