The Bunnygraphs, as a genre, were representative of the cinema of the period, and were very successful, making Bunny the first American comic film star and Finch the first female star comedian.
A Cure for Pokeritis, released February 23, 1912, was individually well-received, including in showings outside the United States. The
Thames Star, a New Zealand newspaper, described the film as "screamingly funny". After John Bunny's death, interest in his films led Vitagraph in 1917 to announce the re-release of this film (retitled
A Sure Cure for Pokeritis), along with many of his other works, as "Favorite Film Features". However, the comedy style of
A Cure for Pokeritis has not aged well, especially in contrast to
Mack Sennett's
slapstick films and the works of later comedians such as
Charlie Chaplin and
Buster Keaton. According to film scholars Donald McCaffrey and Christopher Jacobs, modern viewers "will hardly get a flicker of a smile" from the film, despite the skill of its actors. 's
Sitting up with a Sick Friend from the
Dogs Playing Poker series depicts a similar event, but with
anthropomorphized dog characters. The film's themes and its relationship to later works have been the subject of critical analysis.
A Cure for Pokeritis may be the first depiction of poker in film, and provides insight into the public's perception of the game at the time as a male-dominated societal ill. This attitude, and a scene similar to the film's plot, is also present in
Cassius Marcellus Coolidge's painting
Sitting up with a Sick Friend, part of the
Dogs Playing Poker series commissioned in 1903.
A Cure for Pokeritis has been compared to
sitcoms of both the 1940s and the end of the 20th century. Film historian Wes Gehring of
Ball State University considers George to be a forerunner of the modern
antihero archetype and compares the Browns to
Laurel and Hardy. Other authors have examined the film's gender issues.
Gerald Mast wrote that the comedic aspects overlaid a conflict between
masculinity and
moralist or
feminist values.
Brunel University lecturer Geoff King viewed the male lead's efforts to escape from an "imprisoning" wife to be a recurring theme in silent comedy, and film reviewer Peter Nash found the "fastidious and effeminate" Freddie an example of a contemporary gay stock character. In 2011, this film was selected for preservation in the United States
National Film Registry by the
Library of Congress as being a "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant" representative of the Bunnygraph films. ==Home media==