The novel was widely praised in reviews, described as: "fiction at its best," "a dazzling read," and "a grown-up, elegant fairy tale, at least of a kind, with a humane vision of people in all their complicated splendor." Book critic Maureen Corrigan said, "In "A God In Ruins," Atkinson has written a novel that takes its place in the line of powerful works about young men and war, stretching from Stephen Crane's "Red Badge Of Courage" to Kevin Powers' "
The Yellow Birds" and Ben Fountain's "Billy Lynn's Halftime Walk." In
Time,
Lev Grossman closed the review with his only reservation: "while
A God in Ruins is as finely crafted as
Life After Life, which is saying a lot–everything–it's not as much fun." Barbara Wheatley noted that "A careful look would show the overall plots of
Life After Life and
A God in Ruins as precise mirror images of each other.(...)
Life After Life is overshadowed by Teddy's death in aerial battle over Germany. Deeply grieving for her lost lover, Nancy tells Teddy's sister Ursula: "He would never get married and have children, never live the wonderful life he deserved". But at the very end of the book, Teddy miraculously comes back from the dead. Ursula compares herself and Nancy, come to meet him, with the
Marys meeting the resurrected
Jesus. Yet, as depicted in
A God in Ruins, the life of the risen Teddy turned out to be far from satisfactory. His marriage was cut tragically short by Nancy's brain tumor, his fatherhood fatally blighted by the unrelenting hatred of his only child Viola, and his old age marked by humiliating degeneration and degradation at an inhuman "
nursing home". Given at the last moment a chance to go back and change the way his life had gone, Teddy chooses to die as a young, self-sacrificing war hero - a bit reminiscent of the choice made by
Achilles in
Greek mythology. And thus, this book ends with Nancy and Ursula once again deeply grieving for the dead Teddy. Nancy cannot ever know that, in renouncing his post-war life, Teddy had also created a future in which she would be saved from the brain tumor – though it would be at the side of another man." ==References==