Critical response Chuck Wilson and Ernest Hardy of
LA Weekly praised the film, writing "[f]or their first film since winning the 2006 Outfest Audience Award for The Gymnast, writer-director Ned Farr and his wife, actress Dreya Weber, have made a huge artistic leap forward", and he admired "the fascinating, subtle beauty of Weber's portrayal of a woman who's been holding herself within for so long that she can barely breathe." David Wiegand of
San Francisco Chronicle wrote of the military policy of '
Don't ask, don't tell' being predominant at the Frameline festival in 2010, with "
Marine Story being one of the winners, regardless of what happens with the official U.S. policy toward gays in the military." He shared that "[t]his film does not go where you might think it will go because it's so credibly written, acted and directed." Dennis Harvey of
Variety wrote "Despite the rather bleak setting and content,
A Marine Story has tough-love humor and affection for its characters, who become very likable as things proceed. A violent blast of climactic meth-lab drama works well, as does a poignant, reserved coda. Through it all, Weber (the helmer's spouse and star of his prior feature,
The Gymnast) is first-rate, and other cast members are assured; ditto the modest but expert assembly." Gary M. Kramer of
Philadelphia Gay News wrote "One surefire highlight at QFest this year is lesbian centerpiece selection
A Marine Story, written and directed by Ned Farr and starring Dreya Weber. (The pair collaborated on
The Gymnast a few years back.) This excellent character study has Alexandra (Weber) returning home after an honorable discharge from the Marines. Caught in the “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” crossfire, Alexandra is now re-evaluating her life. Her efforts, which include drinking too much and reflecting on her expulsion, also involve exploring a new relationship and training Saffron (Paris Pickard), a troubled girl, for the military.
A Marine Story is consistently smart and engrossing, and Weber is again outstanding in the title role." Sophia Hoffman of
Velvet Park Media wrote "There have always been films about soldiers returning from war. Prodigal sons returning to their hometowns as patriotic heroes, usually with darkness inside them, scars from their time in combat lurking beneath the surface. It is rare to encounter a film about female soldier returning from war and rarer still that she is returning not only from Iraq but also from an on-going battle with an archaic and close-minded policy.
A Marine’s Story highlights not only the difficulties of a female soldier returning from war but that of a gay soldier, who despite her commitment to and love for her country, is discharged from service because of her sexual orientation."
Awards and nominations • 2010, Won "Audience Award for Outstanding Dramatic Feature,
Outfest • 2010, Won 'Grand Jury Award for Outstanding Dramatic Feature,
Outfest • 2010, Won 'Outstanding Actress in a Feature' for Dreya Weber,
Outfest • 2010, Won 'Grand Jury Prize, Colorado Film Festival • 2010, Won 'Screenwriting award – Feature', Colorado Film Festival ==See also==