A Quiet Word with ... was generally well regarded by critics and reviewers.
Fairfax Media television critics
Doug Anderson and Greg Hassall reviewed the program positively, reflecting that while Martin approached some guests as a fan, the conversations were generally conducted as being between colleagues, allowing the interviewees to become relaxed and sometimes quite revealing with the information that they would then become willing to share. Rachel Browne of
The Sydney Morning Herald stated that the conversation with Oscar nominated American actor
Lily Tomlin showed Martin to be a talented interviewer with "just the right note of inquisitiveness in this well-researched interview". Similarly, Matt Smith wrote on electronic magazine
Crikey that "Tony Martin’s interviews are like no other, he knows the guests’ background to the nth degree, and asks the questions that wouldn't occur to a more conventional host with glasses". However, Louise Schwartzkoff of
The Age wrote that Martin's conversation with his long-time friend
Rob Sitch was like attending "your partner's office Christmas drinks", with the "shop talk and name-dropping" being beyond the ability of casual viewers to follow or enjoy. ==References==