In 2015,
Uncut ranked ''A Toot and a Snore in '74
at number 40 in their list of the 50 best bootlegs. Uncut'' describe it as a recording of "unspectacular banter and similarly unlegendary music", while Wonder "attempts magnificently to paper over the cracks", and categorise its sound quality as "documentarily satisfactory/quiet/poor". They concluded: "An interesting encounter, but one maybe more romantically memorialised by the snapshot of a moustachioed Macca visiting Lennon at home in LA, taken by
Keith Moon's minder,
Dougal Butler."
Rock's Backpages similarly described the recording as a jam and commented that its title is "a pretty fair description of many of the other sessions on which the by-now very hard-living Keys also played during this time." Erik Himmelsbach of the same site writes that despite being notable as Lennon and McCartney's final recording together, "the title of a 30-minute bootleg of the jam –
A Toot and a Snore – says it all. The music was a mess, but Lennon was apparently a gracious host with the blow: 'Do you want a snort, Stevie, a toot? It's going around,' he's heard on the
Toot tape." Jayson Greene of
Pitchfork writes that the bootleg title "came from cocaine, and it sounds that way", describing the session as "mythical, and yet the result was atrocious." Lennon biographer James A. Mitchell notes that despite its later issue as a bootleg, the impromptu performance was not something that would have been officially released, as it consists of "scattered bits and pieces of songs pulled from strained memories amid the unspoken expectations. It was fun, but the time and place weren't feted for anything further."
Jimmy Iovine, a witness to the session, commented that McCartney chose to play drums "because he was alert enough to say, 'This is not how the Beatles are getting back together'. He was the one in the room who you could see got it." McCartney reflected in 2007: "I'm afraid it was a rather
heady session, shall we say. I don't think it was very good. I mean, that is kinda proof really that [a Beatles reunion] wouldn't necessarily have been great." ==Track listing==