One morning in 1991, alcoholic
NYPD Detective Matt Scudder is drinking at his usual bar when three criminals kill the bartender in an attempted shakedown. Scudder pursues them and, in a chaotic gun battle, kills two and cripples the third. Eight years later, Scudder is retired and sober, working as an unlicensed private investigator. Peter Kristo, a fellow
Alcoholics Anonymous member struggling with heroin addiction, introduces Scudder to his brother Kenny, a wealthy drug trafficker. Kenny explains that his wife Carrie was abducted and though he delivered the ransom, the kidnappers dismembered her, leaving him a recording of her brutal rape and murder. Agreeing to find the killers, Scudder visits the
New York Public Library to research similar murders and meets TJ, a homeless teen with a knack for detective work. Scudder comes across the murders of two other women: Leila Andresen, whose dismembered body was found in a pond at
Green-Wood Cemetery, and Marie Gotteskind, a low-level drug dealer. He discerns that Leila's fiancé, Reuben Quintana, is also tied to the drug trade, and questions both him and Jonas Loogan, the cemetery groundskeeper. Reuben tells Scudder he saw three men grab Leila and force her into a van. After catching TJ following him and reluctantly enlisting his help, Scudder tails Jonas to a shack atop an apartment building across the street from Reuben's and discovers evidence Jonas was stalking Leila. Jonas admits he wanted to save Leila from Reuben and was approached by two men who claimed to be DEA agents, helping them kidnap Leila and fleeing when they began torturing her. Overcome with guilt, Jonas
steps off the roof after telling Scudder that one of the kidnappers called himself Ray. While searching the neighborhood Marie dealt drugs out of, Scudder is attacked by two dealers who tell him she was an undercover
DEA agent. Scudder realizes the killers are using her files to target local dealers, kidnapping their loved ones for ransom and murdering them anyway. He tells Kenny to spread the word amongst his fellow dealers, knowing the pair intend to keep their scheme going. After noticing a white van with a fake company logo following him, Scudder is accosted by DEA agents who deny knowing Marie and attempt to pressure him into admitting he is working for Kenny. He confronts Peter, who had informed on Kenny to Marie out of jealousy, unknowingly providing the information that allowed the killers to kidnap Carrie. TJ is beaten by neighborhood dealers for stealing a handgun, and Scudder visits him in the hospital to learn he has
sickle cell anemia. Scudder reveals that a young girl was accidentally killed in the shootout in 1991, prompting him to quit the force and swear off drinking. One of Kenny's fellow traffickers, Yuri Landau, discovers his teenage daughter Lucia was taken by the killers, Ray and Albert, while caring for her ailing mother. When the kidnappers call, Scudder convinces them to return Lucia alive in exchange for one million dollars. Meeting at Green-Wood, Scudder delivers the money and Lucia is reunited with her father, but Albert discovers much of the cash is counterfeit. In the ensuing shootout, Peter is killed while Albert and a wounded Ray escape in their van, unaware TJ is hiding in the back. TJ sees Albert strangle Ray and calls Scudder, leading him and Kenny to the killers' house. Leaving Albert's fate in Kenny's hands, Scudder sends TJ to his apartment in a taxi, but returns to find Albert has broken free and killed Kenny. Albert ambushes Scudder and attacks him with a cleaver, but Scudder subdues him with Ray's taser before shooting him in the head. Watching from afar as police arrive, Scudder returns home. ==Cast==