Mickal was an all-around player; a
triple-threat running back who also played on defense. He was regarded as an excellent deep-ball
passer; in the words of LSU coach
Lawrence "Biff" Jones: "Mickal is a greater passer than
Red Cagle—he's the greatest I ever saw." He was also known for his play-making ability during crucial moments of games, and LSU compiled a
win–loss record of 23–4–5 in the three seasons Mickal played for the team.
1933 Mickal showed his versatility in the first game of the
1933 season against
Rice, tossing a 40-yard pass on the first play from scrimmage to
end Pete Burge and booting punts of 76 and 61 yards. In week four against
Arkansas Mickal completed touchdown passes of 48 and 57 yards and ran for a 15-yard touchdown, as he was responsible for every score in the 20–0 win over the eventual
Southwest Conference champion Razorbacks. He scored the only touchdown of LSU's final game of the season, against
Tennessee, with a goal line dive into the end zone. He also kicked the extra point for the 7–0 victory, and completed the season having successfully made every extra point he attempted. The Tigers finished undefeated with three ties in their first season as members of the
Southeastern Conference (SEC). After the season, Mickal was named to the
United Press (UP)
All-SEC second team as a halfback.
1934 One of Mickal's most notable games came in
1934 against the Mustangs of
Southern Methodist. In week four against 13th-ranked
Arkansas, Mickal completed five of seven passes for 117 yards, which included a 52-yard bomb in the third quarter for the first score of the 16–0 win. He also averaged over 50 yards per punt on nine punts. The next week he threw a touchdown pass, kicked a field goal, and averaged over 40 yards per punt in a 29–0 win over previously undefeated
Vanderbilt. Mickal was named a first-team
All-SEC selection as a fullback by the
Associated Press (AP) and as a halfback by the UP.
Senatorship offer During the season, Mickal was acclaimed an honorary
Louisiana State Senator by
U.S. Senator Huey P. Long, whom he had befriended, at a burlesque campus meeting. Long was a noted LSU supporter and was highly involved in operations of the football program. When it came time for his ceremonial "seating" Mickal refused to appear for the ceremony, despite the urging of Long. After Long reasoned with the senate and spectators that Mickal "had to study," Mickal was granted a five-day leave of absence by senator
Harvey Peltier to "do his work at school and go forward with his preparation for his football duties." Mickal remained silent on the matter, however; he did not give a reason for his refusal of the honor. LSU faced the
TCU Horned Frogs at the end of the season in the
Sugar Bowl, in a game that was a highly anticipated match-up between Mickal and the Horned Frogs'
Sammy Baugh. The offenses were unable to do much, however, as rain throughout the day had muddied the field. TCU won the game, 3–2. LSU finished the season undefeated in conference play for its first
SEC championship. Mickal was named to the AP
All-SEC second-team as a fullback after the season, and earned second-team
All-America honors from
Liberty magazine.
1936 All-Stars vs. Bears In September 1936, Mickal played quarterback for the Centennial College All-Stars, a team composed of college players from
southern schools to play against the
National Football League's
Chicago Bears at
Cotton Bowl stadium. He scored the All-Stars' only touchdown with a dive into the end zone from the one-foot line in the third quarter. The Bears scored their only touchdown later that quarter on a 5-yard run by
Bronko Nagurski. Mickal had a chance to tackle Nagurski before the goal line. "A lot of things flashed through my mind," explained Mickal. "There was nothing between him and the goal line but me. I thought about making the perfect tackle and reading about being the All-Stars' hero. Then I thought about Nagurski's size. I thought about the Nagurski legend. I thought about going to med school. I thought about possible brain damage." It was the first time a team of college players defeated a professional American football team.
Extracurricular Mickal was actively involved in the university's
Reserve Officers' Training Corps. He received the Outstanding Cadet Award as a freshman and was
regimental sergeant major as a junior. As a senior, he attained the rank of
Cadet Colonel and earned the Kemper Williams Sabre as the school's outstanding cadet. Additionally, he was a member of the
pre-med club and debate team, and in 1936 was president of the school's
Interfraternity Council, college of arts and sciences, and student body. Mickal was a member of the
Theta Kappa Nu fraternity. ==Medical career==