Things came to a head in early August 1692, when Elizabeth Johnson's daughter and namesake was accused of witchcraft and arrested. Faulkner's niece quickly confessed, telling her examiners on August 10, that she had consorting with the devil, meeting him at a gathering of "about six score". Faulkner was soon accused of witchcraft by neighbors who claimed she had "afflicted" their children. On August 11, she was arrested and taken to
Salem, where she was interrogated by
Jonathan Corwin,
John Hathorne and Captain John Higginson. He confessed that he had signed the devil's book, and that Satan had promised to "pay all his debts" and allow him to live in luxury. She held a handkerchief in her hands while she was examined, and whenever she would squeeze or twist the cloth, her accusers would have "grievous fitts". When
magistrates demanded to know why she harmed the girls, asking her to look at their distress, Faulkner told the magistrates that she was
"sorry the girls were afflicted", but that she had not afflicted them,
"it is the devil [who] does it in my shape." Faulkner was reexamined the next day in prison, still insisting she had never consorted with the devil, nor signed his book, but did admit to feeling animosity toward her family's accusers. She suggested that the devil had taken advantage of this, in essence framing her for the crime of witchcraft. They refused to implicate anyone else in their activities. On September 8, Faulkner's sister-in-law, Deliverance Dane, confessed to witchcraft under examination, though she would later recant insisting that she had "wronged the truth" by confessing. Faulkner's nine-year-old daughter Abigail was accused of witchcraft and arrested on September 16. The next day her twelve-year-old daughter Dorothy was arrested on the same charge. One day later,
Ann Putnam Jr. testified that she had been "afflicted" by Faulkner on August 9, 1692, and that she had witnessed Faulkner or her
specter tormenting two other young women. ==Aftermath and exoneration==