Many different designs of rack rail and matching cog wheel have been developed over the years. Except for some early
Morgan and
Blenkinsop rack installations, rack systems place the rack rail halfway between the running rails, mounted on the same
sleepers or ties as the running rails.
Blenkinsop (1812) John Blenkinsop thought that the friction would be too low from metal wheels on metal rails even on level ground, so he built his
steam locomotives for the
Middleton Railway in 1812 with a 20-
tooth, diameter cog wheel (pinion) on the left side that engaged in rack teeth (two teeth per foot) on the outer side of the rail, the metal "fishbelly"
edge rail with its side rack being cast all in one piece, in lengths. Blenkinsop's system remained in use for 25 years on the Middleton Railway, but it became a curiosity because simple friction proved sufficient for railroads operating on level ground.
Fell (1860s) The
Fell mountain railway system, developed in the 1860s, is not, strictly speaking, a rack railway, since it has no cogs with teeth. Rather, this system uses a smooth, raised center rail between the two running rails on steep sections of the line, which is gripped on both sides to increase friction. Trains are propelled by wheels or braked by shoes pressed horizontally onto the center rail, as well as by means of the normal running wheels.
Marsh (1861) The first successful rack railway in the United States was the Mount Washington Cog Railway, developed by
Sylvester Marsh. Marsh was issued a U.S.
patent for the general idea of a rack railway in September 1861, and in January 1867 for a practical rack where the rack teeth take the form of rollers arranged like the rungs of a ladder between two L-shaped wrought-iron rails. The first public trial of the Marsh rack on Mount Washington was made on August 29, 1866, when only one quarter of a mile (402 meters) of track had been completed. The Mount Washington railway opened to the public on August 14, 1868. The pinion wheels on the locomotives have deep teeth that ensure that at least two teeth are engaged with the rack at all times; this measure helps reduce the possibility of the pinions riding up and out of the rack. The use of multiple bars with offset teeth ensures that the pinions on the locomotive driving wheels are constantly engaged with the rack. The Abt system is cheaper to build than the Riggenbach because it requires a lower weight of rack over a given length. However, the Riggenbach system exhibits greater wear resistance than the Abt. and in 1893 by the Japanese Government Railways on the section between Yokokawa and Karuizawa in the
Usui Pass. It is used today on the
Ikawa Line of the
Ōigawa Railway. The pinion wheels can be mounted on the same axle as the rail wheels, or driven separately. The steam locomotives on the
West Coast Wilderness Railway have separate cylinders driving the pinion wheel, as do the
"X"-class locomotives on the
Nilgiri Mountain Railway.
Agudio (1884) The Agudio rack system was invented by Tommaso Agudio. Its only long-lived application was on the
Sassi–Superga tramway, which opened in 1884. It used a vertical rack with cog wheels on each side of the central rack. Its unique feature, however, was that the 'locomotive' was propelled by means of an endless cable driven from an engine house at the foot of the incline. It was converted to use the Strub rack system in 1934.
Locher (1889) The Locher rack system, invented by
Eduard Locher, has
gear teeth cut in the sides rather than the top of the rail, engaged by two cog wheels on the locomotive. This system allows use on steeper grades than the other systems, whose teeth could jump out of the rack. It is used on the
Pilatus Railway. Locher set out to design a rack system that could be used on gradients as steep as 1 in 2 (50%). The Abt system – the most common rack system in
Switzerland at the time – was limited to a maximum gradient of 1 in 4 (25%). Locher showed that on steeper grades, the Abt system was prone to the driving pinion overriding the rack, causing potentially catastrophic derailments, as predicted by Dr. Abt. To overcome this problem and allow a rack to line up the steep sides of
Mt. Pilatus, Locher developed a rack system where the rack is a flat bar with symmetrical, horizontal teeth. Horizontal pinions with flanges below the rack engage the centrally mounted bar, both driving the locomotive and keeping it centered on the track. This system provides a very stable attachment to the track, also protecting the car from toppling over even under the most severe crosswinds. Such gears can also lead the car, so even flanges on running wheels are optional. The biggest shortcoming of the system is that the standard
railway switch is unusable, and a
transfer table or other complex device must be used where track branching is needed. Following tests, the Locher system was deployed on the Pilatus Railway, which opened in 1889. No other public railway uses the Locher system, although some European coal mines use a similar system on steeply graded underground lines. The best-known use of the Strub system is on the
Jungfraubahn in Switzerland.
Morgan (1900) In 1900, E. C. Morgan of
Chicago received a patent for a rack railway system that was mechanically similar to the Riggenbach rack, but in which the rack was also used as a
third rail to power the electric locomotive. Morgan went on to develop heavier locomotives and with J. H. Morgan,
turnouts for this system. In 1904, he patented a simplified but compatible rack, where the teeth on the engine pinions engaged square holes punched in a bar-shaped center rail. J. H. Morgan patented several alternative turnout designs for use with this rack system. Curiously, Morgan recommended an off-center rack to allow clear passage for pedestrians and animals walking along the tracks. A simplified rack mounting system could be used when the Morgan rack was not used for third-rail power and the Morgan rack offered interesting possibilities for street railways. The Morgan rack was good for grades of up to 16
percent. The Goodman Equipment Company began marketing the Morgan system for
mine railways, and it saw widespread use, particularly where steep
grades were encountered underground. By 1907, Goodman had offices in
Cardiff, Wales, to serve the British market. Between 1905 and 1906, the Mammoth Vein Coal Company installed of powered rack in two of its mines in
Everist, Iowa, with a maximum grade of 16%. The Donohoe Coke Co. of
Greenwald, Pennsylvania had of Goodman rack in its mine in 1906. The Morgan system saw limited use on one
common carrier railroad in the United States, the
Chicago Tunnel Company, a
narrow-gauge freight carrier that had one steep grade in the line up to their surface disposal station on the
Chicago lakefront.
Lamella in
New South Wales, Australia The Lamella system (also known as the Von Roll system) was developed by the
Von Roll company after the rolled steel rails used in the Strub system became unavailable. It is formed from a single blade cut in a similar shape to the Abt system, but typically wider than a single Abt bar. The Lamella rack can be used by locomotives designed for use on the Riggenbach or the Strub systems, so long as the safety-jaws that were a feature of the original Strub system are not used. Some railways use racks from multiple systems; for example, the
St. Gallen Gais Appenzell Railway in Switzerland had, until 2018 (opening of the Ruckhalde tunnel avoiding rack), sections of Riggenbach, Strub, and Lamella rack. Most of the rack railways built from the late 20th century onwards have used the Lamella system. == Switches ==