Acheloma was named by
Edward Drinker Cope in 1882 based on a partial skull with associated postcranial elements from the
Arroyo Formation of Texas; the specimen is currently reposited at the
American Museum of Natural History in New York. Subsequent discoveries of large trematopids from the Arroyo Formation were named as different species of
Trematops (
T. milleri, T. willistoni), but these have since been synonymized with
Acheloma cumminsi.
Trematops stonei from the Washington Formation of Ohio and
Trematops thomasi from Oklahoma have also been synonymized with
A. cumminsi. A second species of
Acheloma was described by Polley & Reisz (2011) from the Richards Spur locality in Oklahoma. A 2020 paper by Gee synonymized
A. dunni with
A. cumminsi, suggesting that
ontogeny may account for the differences in specimens. However, the 2024 paper from Osterling Arias et al., which established the new species
A. cryptatheria from a reexamined block of Richards Spur material, resurrected the species of
A. dunni based on considerations of internal skull morphology. == Anatomy ==