Due to conflicting details across several sources that claim different origins of Achi no Omi, several theories have been proposed by modern historians. In the earliest accounts such as the
Kojiki (712) and the
Nihon Shoki (720) state that Achi no Omi and his clan had originated from the kingdom of
Paekche. However, according to
Shoku Nihongi (797), it is said that he was the great-grandson of
Emperor Ling of Han which is the reason why his clan was named "東漢" meaning "
Eastern Han" in
Chinese characters. In contrast, according to the claim made by the
Sakanoue clan,
Yamatonoaya's cadet branch clan, Achi no Omi was a descendant of
Emperor Xian of Han being either his grandson or great grandson and not Emperor Ling in the
Shinsen Shōjiroku (815). These claims made by blood relatives (Yamatonoaya–Sakanoue) conflict with each other causing genealogical confusion among modern historians. It is very likely that the added information and claims are aggrandizations made by the authors to emphasize the clan's importance as older sources (
Kojiki &
Nihon Shoki) do not mention anything about Achi no Omi being related to Chinese royalty. According to historian (栗田 寛), it was common for Korean descendants to rely on prominent families for their lineage in order to raise their social status. Modern Japanese scholars have indicated that Yamatonoaya clan and other "Aya (漢)" clans were all related and that they were generally classified under the same ethnic group. These mainly included: the
Aya clan (漢氏), the
Ayahito clan (漢人氏), the Yamatonoaya clan (東漢氏/倭漢氏) and the
Kawachinoaya clan (西漢氏/河内漢氏). It is said that Yamatonoaya clan, Aya and Kawachinoaya, though not from the same founder, were ethnically related, most likely all immigrating from
Paekche. Regardless of the claims found in the sources, the truth surrounding Achi no Omi and the other prominent immigrants such as
Wani and
Yuzuki no Kimi remain skeptical with modern historians considering them as fictional individuals whose stories were added later to help create origin stories for clans with foreign backgrounds. == Name ==