Upon publication, the book received many reviews, and Robinson and Gallagher's work has been described as having far reaching influence. In his introduction to the 1998
The Oxford History of the British Empire,
Wm. Roger Louis described their work as creating "a conceptual revolution." The book provided a context of expansion that focused on events outside of Europe.
The Canadian Historical Review declared that "Students of African or imperial history must read this book, and will enjoy reading it." A reviewer in
The Journal of Modern History described it as a "remarkable book". They described the book as "rewriting" the history and interpretation of the scramble. Writing in
The Economic History Review,
D. K. Fieldhouse felt that the authors made a "very strong case" but felt they attributed too much of the scramble as a response to British expansion in Egypt. He also felt that the book felt repetitive at times, but was generally a "very impressive piece of research and argument...perhaps the sanest and most convincing interpretation yet published of the real character of British imperialism in the late 19th century." A reviewer in
The American Historical Review felt that the argument presented would be "startling" to
African nationalists and
economic determinists but was well supported and persuasive, concluding it was a "well written, stimulating essay."
George Shepperson reviewed the book in
The English Historical Review, concluding that the book was more realistic than others of its genre, considering it an important would that was "certain to be influential" but questioning the heavy reliance on official records, which he felt often omitted details or context, and saying that its theorizing represented the weakest parts. Shepperson concluded that the book was generally excellent. A reviewer in
Transition called the book "very important... but also extremely entertaining [and] delightfully written". == References ==