Critical At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics,
Human After All received an
average score of 57, indicating "mixed or average reviews", based on 28 reviews.
Q felt that it lacked the "fun" of Daft Punk's previous work. Barry Walters of
Rolling Stone said that the duo generally "repeats rather than elaborates its riffs", and that they "exaggerate their band's own robotic tendencies here, much to the detriment of its grooves". of
The Guardian called the album "a joyless collection of average ideas stretched desperately thin".
Robert Christgau from
The Village Voice graded the album a "dud", indicating "a bad record whose details rarely merit further thought".
Mixmag wrote that
Human After All sounded "as if Bangalter took a holiday and let his four year-old son ... loose in the studio with a toy sound machine".
Mojo magazine said that it "strips out the most flamboyant frills to create a more incisive sound".
Human After All was nominated for the 2006
Grammy Award for Best Electronic/Dance Album, but lost to
the Chemical Brothers album
Push the Button.
Commercial The album topped the
Billboard Top Dance/Electronic Albums chart and 80,838 copies in the UK. The first single from the album, "Robot Rock", received moderate attention, reaching number 32 in the UK and number 15 on the
Billboard Hot Dance Club Songs chart, but was not a major hit. The second single, "Technologic", reached number 40 in the UK but did considerably better in airplay and was featured in an
iPod commercial. "Human After All" reached number 93 in France. == Legacy ==