Mick Sinclair describes "After Dark in the Playing Fields" as "slight but curious".
E. F. Bleiler describes it as "a mood piece about trees, birds, and the talking owl pursued by a something that may get the narrator, too". Both
S. T. Joshi and Peter Bell note similarities in atmosphere and tone between "After Dark in the Playing Fields" and James' 1922 children's fantasy novel
The Five Jars. Similarly, the
London Mercury described it as "...almost a meditation, and a pendant to the lovely, fear-touched imaginations of
The Five Jars" that "may have in it something of Doctor James' personal belief". Rosemary Pardoe describes it as "a seriously underrated story" that "is more important than it at first seems", describing it as a more sinister "companion tale" to
The Five Jars. Similarly, William Atkinson writes that "The invisible population of 'After Dark in the Playing Fields,' although more sinister, is reminiscent of the little people of
The Five Jars." Rosemary Pardoe also suggests that "After Dark in the Playing Fields" inspired
Ramsey Campbell's 1981 short story "The Burning". Jane Mainley-Piddock notes "This tale is exceptional in that the narrator is none other than James himself. It is one of only two tales where the Jamesian tactic of narratorial distance is not maintained (the other being '
A Vignette'), which somewhat undermines the theories that many critics (and James) maintained that distance is necessary to maintain plausibility." ==References==