Born in
Bern, Sutter played youth football for
SC Bümpliz 78, before beginning his professional career in 1985 with
Grasshoppers, one of Switzerland's most storied clubs. After spending the 1987–88 season on loan at
BSC Young Boys, he was ready to take his place in the Grasshoppers first team, where he remained until the 1993–94 season, when he decided to move to Germany to play with
1. FC Nürnberg. After Sutter's impressive performances during the
1994 FIFA World Cup, Germany's most successful club,
Bayern Munich, quickly signed the midfielder where he played for one season, In 1997, he transferred to
Major League Soccer in the United States, where he signed for the Dallas Burn (now
FC Dallas). He played one season in Dallas but his tenure there was cut short when, during training in early 1998, he stepped awkwardly in a hole of the practice field (the Burn was using the facilities of a high school at that time) and the injury forced him to retire. He ended his career with 68
caps and five goals for the
Swiss national team. ==Retirement==