Arraignment At his initial
arraignment the day after the shootings, Cruz was charged with 17 counts of
premeditated murder and held without
bond. According to an affidavit by the sheriff's office, Cruz confessed to the shooting. It was also claimed Cruz told officers that he brought additional loaded magazines hidden in a backpack. Cruz was placed on
suicide watch in an
isolation cell (solitary confinement) after the arraignment. Lead defense counsel Gordon Weekes asked Broward Circuit Judge
Elizabeth Scherer to
recuse herself, claiming that her previous comments and rulings showed favoritism toward the prosecution, which would prevent Cruz from receiving a
fair trial. She disagreed and declined the request on .
2018 On , a
grand jury indicted Cruz on a total of 34 charges: 17 counts of first-degree murder and 17 counts of attempted first-degree murder. He was arraigned on , and the prosecution filed notice of their intent to seek the death penalty. They said they could prove five of
the aggravating factors that qualify a murder for the death penalty in Florida. Cruz declined to enter a plea, so Scherer entered "not guilty" on his behalf. The defense had earlier offered a guilty plea if the death penalty was taken off the table, and reiterated it immediately before it was refused. During the week of April 8–12, 2018, Scherer included a three-page letter from a Minnesotan into the court record of the case. The letter was addressed to the judge and claimed that research into Cruz's past led the writer to believe that Cruz had a
developmental disability and that he was "fearful of other people and was threatened by bullies." The letter ended by claiming that Cruz appeared to be consumed by sadness and depression. The same week, a hearing was held to determine if Cruz was entitled to a public defender. His attorney, court-appointed public defender
Howard Finkelstein, asked the court to wait until the probate case involving Cruz's late mother's estate was concluded and Cruz's net worth could be determined, as Cruz would have only been entitled to a public defender had he been unable to afford a private attorney. According to the Broward County Sheriff's Office, Cruz attacked a jail officer on the night of November 13, 2018. The following day, he was charged with aggravated assault on an officer, battery against an officer, and use of an "electric or chemical weapon against an officer". The officer who was allegedly attacked by Cruz had asked him to "not drag his sandals on the ground" while he was walking in the jail's dayroom. It was claimed Cruz responded by "displaying his middle finger" and striking the officer in the face. He also grabbed the stun gun out of the deputy's holster. The weapon discharged during the brawl before the deputy regained control and Cruz was placed in solitary confinement. Cruz appeared at an initial hearing on the assault charges, where bail was set at $200,000.
2019 On April 24, 2019, a determination was made that Cruz and his half-brother Zachary would share the proceeds of a MetLife insurance policy valued at $864,929. This would make Cruz ineligible for representation by the public defender's office, and the office therefore asked to be removed from his case on that date. Scherer ruled on July 26 that Cruz's confession would be released to the public, adding on August 3 that the Broward school district's report on Cruz would also be released, with some redactions to protect Cruz's
privacy rights. The confession was released on August 6. On August 8, a video of Cruz's
confession filmed by the Broward County Sheriff's Office was published by
TMZ. Cruz can be heard crying near the end of the video, and saying "kill me" to the camera.
2020 Cruz's trial, initially scheduled to begin on January 27, 2020, was originally delayed until mid-year to allow his lawyers more time to build their case. The case was then delayed again due to the
COVID-19 pandemic; the case was expected to go to trial in September 2021. However, a start date for the trial was not set.
2021 Before the trial, the judge,
Elizabeth Scherer, ruled that the use of "derogatory words" to refer to Cruz would not be allowed from prosecutors or witnesses during the trial, saying that it would not be feasible to create an "exhaustive list of words" that should not be used to describe Cruz. However, Judge Scherer also ruled against the defense in the use of some words, ruling that Cruz can be called "killer", "school shooter" or "murderer" as she deemed those words "normal to describe particular facts." On October 14, a trial was scheduled for the following day, where it was reported that Cruz would plead guilty to the battery charge. Judge Scherer stated she would hold a hearing on October 20, where Cruz planned to plead guilty to all counts relating to the shooting to avoid the death penalty. On October 20, Cruz pleaded guilty to all charges, including murder and attempted murder. Cruz made a statement after pleading guilty in which he expressed remorse for his crimes and asked the victims' families to decide his fate.
2022 Cruz's death penalty trial began July 18, 2022, and was presided over by Judge Scherer. On July 27, 2022, prosecutors presented the jurors
digital evidence in their investigation. Jurors were presented with an 18-page list of search queries from various
Google accounts. "how to become a school shooter", "Why I want to kill woman", and "pumped up kicks columbine high school" (a reference to the song "
Pumped Up Kicks"). On August 4, 2022, the prosecution rested its case. On August 20, 2022, the
Sun Sentinel released drawings written by Cruz in prison, which he had created in May. In the drawings, he blamed his ex-girlfriend's new boyfriend for making him do the shooting, who Cruz claimed sexually humiliated him on Instagram before the attack. Anthony Montalto III, the brother of victim Gina Montalto, called Cruz a "murdering bastard"; while Michael Schulman, the father of victim Scott Biegel, said that his wish for his 70th birthday was to hear word that Cruz had been killed in prison. The defense presented the jurors evidence and expert testimony that Cruz suffered from brain damage and disabilities resulting from his birth mother smoking, drinking alcohol and using various illegal drugs during her pregnancy with him and failure by the state and the school and other sources to get him proper treatment. It was also alleged by Cruz that he was repeatedly molested and raped at age nine by a twelve-year-old neighbor. In a rebuttal, an expert witness for the prosecution testified that Cruz faked
fetal alcohol syndrome in a psychiatric evaluation and diagnosed him with both
antisocial and
borderline personality disorder. The defense team for Cruz rested their case on September 14, 2022. The prosecution's rebuttal began on September 27, 2022, and ended on September 29, 2022. Cruz's Google and YouTube search history were presented to the court, showing searches of child pornography, rape, racism, Nazism, misogyny and killing animals. Closing arguments were delivered on October 11, 2022. On October 13, 2022, the jury recommended that Cruz be sentenced to
life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. While the jury found that the state had proven
beyond a reasonable doubt the aggravating factors on all counts, they were not unanimous on whether the aggravating factors outweighed the mitigating factors. Nearly all of the murdered victims' families expressed anger and extreme disappointment toward the verdict, stating in their
victim impact statements that he deserved the death penalty. Other points of contention from the victims were the perceived improper conduct of Cruz's lawyers during the trial as well as the unanimity required by Florida law to impose the death penalty as opposed to a majority vote. Florida governor
Ron DeSantis, who also criticized the jury's recommendation, called for changes to the law. In April 2023, DeSantis signed a bill allowing juries to recommend the death penalty in capital cases on an 8–4 vote, among other measures. On November 2, 2022, Cruz was sentenced to 34
consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole, one each for the total number of victims murdered and wounded by Cruz.
2025 In June 2025, Cruz settled a civil lawsuit with shooting victim
Anthony Borges, granting Borges rights to Cruz's name so that Cruz cannot grant interviews or make any agreement with film producers or authors without Borges' permission. Borges' lawyer said the objective was to take power and control from Cruz so he "cannot inflict further torture on his victims from jail." Cruz also agreed to posthumously donate his brain to science. == Notes ==