In 1906, during a Legislative Assembly debate over a land corruption scandal,
John Norton the member for
Surry Hills challenged
William Holman, the Labor member for
Cootamundra and a future premier, to resign his seat so that Norton could contest a by-election directly against him. When the challenge was accepted, Norton was compelled to resign from his own seat precipitating a by-election in Surry Hills, which was held on 14 July 1906. Bruntnell stood as the Liberal and Reform candidate and won with 30% of the vote. Norton finished 4th with 18%. At the next state election held on 10 September 1907, Bruntnell chose to contest the seat of
Alexandria but lost to the
Labor Party candidate
John Dacey. Bruntnell was absent from parliament until the general election of 1910 when he won the seat of
Annandale by 200 votes (1.18%). He was, however, defeated at the next election by
Arthur Griffith. Bruntnell was finally able to secure a safe, conservative voting seat, at the 1916 by-election for the seat of
Parramatta. This election was caused by the death of
Thomas Moxham. Bruntnell continued to represent Parramatta until his death. ==Ministerial career==