Having scored an extraordinary 255 goals in three seasons for amateur Sheffield sides All Saints Old Boys and
Atlas & Norfolk, Hutchinson was lured south to play for
Third Division South side
Luton Town in 1929. After impressing in the Luton Reserve side, he was elevated to the first team but only managed five senior appearances and one goal for the Hatters. Hutchinson was then signed by Luton's Third Division South rivals Torquay United before the beginning of the
1930–31 season. Making his debut away to
Newport County on 30 August 1930, he had to give up his favoured
centre forward position to
Jimmy Trotter. However, he immediately established himself as an
inside forward and was an ever-present over the next two seasons. Hutchinson was eventually made United's captain and was the club's leading scorer for both the 1934–35 and 1935–36 seasons. He proved his versatility by playing at every position on the pitch during his Torquay career, even filling in for injured goalkeeper Percy Maggs during a home game against
Brighton & Hove Albion where he managed to save a penalty. Hutchinson eventually returned to Sheffield to work in the steel industry before his death from lung cancer in May 1974. ==Career statistics==