Box office In the United States and Canada,
Ella McCay was projected to gross around $4 million from 2,500 theaters in its opening weekend;
Deadline Hollywood pointed to poor critical reception and speculated: "Once upon a time,
Ella McCay would have clicked ... Prestige drama/dramedies, which audiences used to find in theaters thanks to Brooks, are too prevalent on TV at home. Why leave the house to watch them (now)?" In the second week of its theatrical run,
Ella McCay saw a 77% decline in box office gross. Box office gross declined a further 75% in its third week and 68% in its fourth week.
Critical response Audiences polled by
CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "B-" on an A+ to F scale. Adrian Horton of
The Guardian called the film "...a mess – a clunky collection of incoherent characters and confounding plot that seem to defy basic story logic at every turn, and not in a surprising or intriguing way", and Nick Schager of
The Daily Beast said it was "...woefully short on charm, its plot a contrived hodgepodge of so many similar ’80s and ’90s tales that it plays as a brand-spanking new relic." In positive reviews,
Nell Minow of
RogerEbert.com said, "Its optimism is so refreshing, its dialogue so smart, and its characters and performances so endearing, it well rewards a watch," and Adam Nayman of
Sight and Sound stated, "There are worse feelings to have at a movie than the suspicion that everything will work out just fine for the people who deserve it, and taken on its own terms, Brooks’s tale of virtue as its own reward is sufficiently endearing." The poster inspired an
internet meme known as the Ella McCay Challenge, wherein the challenger attempts to mimic the main character's pose.
Vulture claimed the meme was more popular than the movie, and the reviewer from
Defector stated it inspired her to see the film, summing up her review with "It isn't funny, and it doesn't make any sense." In the aftermath of the poor critical and commercial response, co-star Albert Brooks came to its defense and said: "It got clobbered pretty hard for not being about today, or whatever. I liked the movie. I love Jim (Brooks), and I think Jim, in his sleep, is better than 90 percent of people. But it came out in a time when that kind of movie is not playing in theaters. That is what’s playing on streaming, and it’s unfortunate. I read some of the negative reviews to get a sense of what the issues are, and maybe it was that it feels earnest, but I couldn’t really make heads or tails of it. I think it’s right there with what he does so well… You’re allowed to say, ‘We don’t really want something like that.’ But to get violently angry, I didn’t get it." ==References==