According to scholar Wisam Kh. Abdul-Jabbar,
Alexandria... Why? explores questions of identity, belonging, and national crisis through the eyes of its director, Youssef Chahine. Drawing on his own experiences growing up in 1940s Alexandria, Chahine blends autobiography with historical and political events to show how personal stories are shaped by larger social forces. The film does not present a single, unified idea of what it means to be Egyptian. Instead, it reflects a diverse, conflicted society marked by
colonialism, war, and cultural mixing. Its use of multiple languages, dream-like scenes, and characters from different backgrounds creates a picture of a nation that is searching for itself. The film also shows how private life through family, love, education, and personal dreams is tied up with politics and power. Yahia, the main character, expresses himself through Hollywood fantasies and
Shakespeare in the classroom, using art to both escape and challenge the colonial world around him. One subplot, involving a British soldier and an Egyptian aristocrat, shows how personal relationships can reflect deeper tensions between colonizer and colonized. By weaving these stories together, Chahine suggests that national identity is not something fixed or simple, but something built from many voices and experiences, often in times of struggle and uncertainty. ==See also==