For his portrayal of Alf, Meagher was nominated for Most Popular Actor at the 2008
Digital Spy Soap Awards. In 2010, Meagher won the
Gold Logie at the
Logie Awards. He was also nominated for
Most Popular Actor. Meagher won the Most Popular Actor Logie Award in 2018. That same year, he won Best Daytime Star at the
Inside Soap Awards. Meagher received a nomination for Most Popular Actor at the
2019 Logie Awards. In 2022, Meagher received nominations for the Gold Logie for Most Popular Personality on Australian Television and Most Popular Actor. The following year, he received a nominated for Most Popular Actor. The episode featuring Alf's breakdown following the suicide of an army mate, Jeff Marshall, who served with him in Vietnam, won the 1998
Australian Film Institute Award for Best Episode in a Television Drama Serial and was presented to director Russell Webb. The episode featuring Alf's late wife Ailsa showing him a vision of Summer Bay without him won the 2003
Australian Writers' Guild Award for Best Episode in a Television Serial. It was presented to the episode's writer Coral Drouyn. Robin Oliver from
The Sydney Morning Herald said that Alf and Ailsa formed a "terrific partnership". Rosemarie Milsome of the
Newcastle Herald was critical of Alf's treatment of Chloe Richards breastfeeding her newborn daughter Olivia in the diner, labelling him "The stereotypical ocker middle-aged male; judgmental, laconic and a pain in the backside." She added: "I thought Chloe should have decked Alf, but then I tend to fly off the handle and, anyway, it would have been difficult for her to have a good swing with a baby attached to her nipple."
Holy Soap have said that Alf's most memorable moment is "The classic episode ripping off ''It's A Wonderful Life'', in which Alf, in the middle of a brain tumour operation, is led through Summer Bay history as if he had never existed." They also describe him as "the
Lou Carpenter of Summer Bay, a miserable but lovable legend who will never leave."
Yahoo!7 opined he had become "a TV icon" for using his catchphrases such as "flamin'" and "strewth".
Virgin Media have also agreed he is "lover of stereotypical Aussie slang", stating "Stone the flamin' crows!" has been one of his typical lines. They added that their favourite was "Yer flamin' great galah!" Geoff Mayer, Brian McFlarne and Ina Bertrand said in their book "The Oxford companion to Australian film" that Meagher's roles have epitomised the rough-hewn, knockabout Australian character. They said he portrays the persona in Alf and brands him a popular character. In November 2021, three critics for
The West Australian placed Alf in first place in their feature on the "Top 50 heroes we love and villains we hate" from
Home and Away. Praising the character, they wrote: "Stone the flamin' crows, if Alf Stewart isn't Australia's most iconic TV character of all time then we don't know who is. Alf was one of the show's original 18 characters when
Home and Away launched in 1988 and strewth, would you believe Meagher now holds a Guinness World Record for being the longest-serving actor in an Australian series? Alf is beloved for his no-nonsense approach, his fondness for ocker headwear, dishing out advice (whether wanted or not) and his many catchphrases. including 'flamin' galah!'. The day Meagher retires and Alf is killed off will likely be a day of national mourning." ==References==