Garr was born in
Danville, Kentucky, on July 27, 1875, the youngest child in his family by 12 years. He was
baptized at age seven at a local
Baptist church, after having a conviction of
sin. He continued to feel distant from God, however, as he did not have the real experience with God that he had expected post-baptism. He remained hungry for spiritual encounters in his young age, even traveling to Charleston, Virginia, for a
Presbyterian Church meeting. As a teen, he struggled with his relationship with churches and God, and began using tobacco. While in Kentucky for business, Garr met a preacher from the
Holiness movement. Garr believed the preacher's conviction that he was free of sin, and felt inspired by that notion. After this meeting, Garr said he felt the call of God to
preach, but resisted that call initially. Garr later enrolled in
Asbury College in
Wilmore, Kentucky, in the fall of 1898 to study ministry. Shortly thereafter, he married his wife, Lillian Anderson, on March 12, 1899, and withdrew from Asbury College. They both became ordained with the
Methodist Church and the International Apostolic Prayer Union, led by
Martin Wells Knapp. ==Career==