From December 2013 to December 2017, Watkins was in a romantic relationship with the former head of security for the Senate Intelligence Committee,
James A. Wolfe. The FBI opened an investigation into Wolfe after an April 2017 article by Watkins described contacts between Russian spies and
Donald Trump policy adviser
Carter Page, who had not been publicly identified in relation to those contacts and who was working for the CIA at the time of the meetings. On October 15, 2018, Wolfe pleaded guilty to one count of lying to the FBI about his relationship with Watkins. Prosecutors alleged that Wolfe leaked to Watkins and three other reporters. Watkins denied that Wolfe ever provided her classified information. Watkins disclosed the relationship to her employers BuzzFeed News,
The New York Times, and
Politico; however, McClatchy editors said they were ignorant of the relationship while Watkins was an intern and employee from mid-2013 through 2014. Following the Wolfe relationship, Watkins dated another Senate Intelligence Committee staff member, which Politico, her employer at the time, has said she failed to disclose. Former
New York Times editor
Jill Abramson said “I hate the whole situation more than I can say,” because she had spent her whole career trying to combat the notion that successful female journalists sleep with their sources.
The Sydney Morning Herald reported that the case "bears a strong resemblance to the television drama
House of Cards," of which it said Watkins was a fan. In 2019,
Erik Wemple of
The Washington Post compared Watkins to
Amanda Macias, as did Stephen L. Miller of
The Spectator. ==Operation Whistle Pig==