The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "This everyday story of country folk has no ambition beyond an almost obsessive ordinariness, conveyed not through understatement but through clichés. These dominate the life of simple vet James Herriot, whose daily rounds consist entirely of jolly japes and noble sacrifices, and govern director Claude Whatham's evocation of 1937, which is suffocated by a period charm which becomes less charming by the minute: a pre-war packet of Force is placed prominently on the breakfast table, a '
Stop me and buy one' man is placed prominently in the foreground, and so forth.
Peter Suschitzky's pretty photography is noteworthy; so too is the performance of Anthony Hopkins, whose bluff, irascible veterinarian shines like a beacon amidst otherwise dull or stock characterisation. Overall, however, the film could not be recommended to anyone other than fans of
The Archers and children who derive pleasure from watching people doing unpleasant things to sick animals."
The Times film critic
David Robinson wrote "
All Creatures Great and Small is so wholesome and warmhearted it makes you want to scream. Not on account of these qualities in themselves, but because of the director's (Claude Whatham) inability to give them any more depth or meaning than a television series", but acknowledged that Anthony Hopkins' and Simon Ward's playing made their characters somewhat believable.
Filmink called the movie "charming" but felt its memory had been overshadowed by the later TV series. ==Home media==