In an otherwise positive review of the album,
Rolling Stone wrote about the song: Similarly, Steve Appleford of the
Los Angeles Times called the song "a duet of cheap insults with Bizkit's Fred Durst that only diminishes one of Korn's strongest albums", and the
Winston-Salem Journal wrote, "one wonders how [Davis] could stumble so badly with 'All in the Family' – a scatological song crammed with crude jive and anti-gay jibes that severely undercuts an otherwise potent disc." The
Austin American-Statesmans critic wrote that the song's "pulsating rhythms... are undermined by countless references to guys' private parts, the f- word, 'faggots' and incest." Mike Boehm, commenting in the
Los Angeles Times, attempted to consider the band's motivations in writing the lyrics: He goes on to write, "The ugliness of 'All in the Family' doesn't stem from overt homophobia; let's take Davis at his word that he harbors no ill feelings toward gays. Instead, it embodies the ingrained, unthinking homophobic bias that runs strong in our culture." In 2021,
Kerrang! placed the song on its list of the band's top 20 songs. ==Track listing==