Everything is Love received positive reviews from critics. At
Metacritic, the album has an
average score of 80 out of 100, which indicates "generally favorable reviews" based on 22 reviews. In
The Guardian, Petridis believed the album retreads
braggadocio centering around the duo's wealth and excellence, with less musical daring, but still does so with likeable music, genuine wit, and energy. As per
The Daily Telegraph music critic
Neil McCormick pointed, "
Everything Is Love certainly doesn’t have the musical expansiveness of
Lemonade. There are neither
ballads nor bangers, and not much in the way of melodic song construction at all. Rather, these are snappily repetitive beats on which the stars can put across their message as a form of hip hop conversation." For
Variety, Jim Aswad described it as "solid and generally satisfying, but not the best from either."
Will Hodgkinson of
The Times reviewed track-by-track, stated: "Jay-Z is as dynamic as ever and the new, though Beyoncé demands attention on this
surprise album, [...] despite the ups and downs detailed on Beyoncé's
Lemonade and Jay-Z's subsequent
mea culpa 4:44. Instead they are coming out fighting, with all that fame and money making them defensive, even
paranoid, while a mix of
classic soul, hard-hitting hip-hop and slinky R&B."
Pitchfork contributor Briana Younger wrote that the album "is a compromise between the spoils of
Lemonades war and the fruits of
4:44s labor", and that "within this complex, messy and beautifully black display, the Carters find absolution." Giving the album one and a half stars, Adam Rothbarth of
Tiny Mix Tapes stated that everything about the album "feels superficial, from the artists' constant pronouncement of their love for each other to their engagement with topics like fashion". He also added that the "most boring aspect of the album is its centerpiece: the couple's obsession with their wealth".
Accolades == Commercial performance ==