Writing for
Pitchfork, Joe Tangari described
Alligator as "satisfying and engaging," though "not quite as bracing" as the band's previous album,
Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers. Christian Brodal of
NPR stated that "the band seems to trust the melodies to do the work, letting them unwind slightly surreptitiously and on the best songs hook you with a winning off-hand sweetness," though criticized some songs on the record as feeling "too slight".
Alligator appeared on many year-end top 10 lists, including
Uncut and
Planet Sound, both of which ranked it as the number two album of 2005.
Pitchfork ranked
Alligator at number 40 in their top albums of the 2000s list.
Alligator has sold over 200,000 copies worldwide. In a 2015 retrospective,
Stereogum's Chris Deville stated that "listening to it now is like looking at an old photograph of someone you’ve known forever and being stunned by their childlike vigor." A 2020 retrospective, from
Consequence's Grant Sharples stated that
Alligator was the "first record on which The National are The National," noting that the album was also the first time where a "quiet band decided to get loud." == Track listing ==