Junior football Toby grew up in
Ipswich,
Queensland and began her junior career with
Ipswich City Bulls. At 16 she joined
Annerley FC followed by
Olympic FC.
Adelaide United Toby was recruited to
Adelaide United in the W-League for the
2015–16 season. She subsequently moved back to Queensland to play with the Roar.
Brisbane Roar Toby would go on to win Roar's Golden Boot award with 5 goals in their W-League Premiership winning campaign in 2017/18. She would win the club's Golden Boot award again in the following season after another 5 goal haul.
Moreton Bay United Famalicão In October 2020, Toby was offered a one-year contract by Portuguese club
Famalicão. She flew over and was involved in a pre-season friendly in Spain. A few weeks later the club contacted her to tell her they terminated her contract.
Sydney FC In December 2020, Toby returned to Australia, joining
Sydney FC.
Canberra United In September 2021, Toby joined
Canberra United. ==Personal life==