Butler was born in
Kingston, Jamaica. His youth career began at age 12 with the Golden Star in Port Royal. During the next three years, he had played in the President's Cup, Minor League and Sid Bartlett League. When he was fourteen, Butler left Port Royal All Age School for Dunoon Technical High School, where he played for the school's football team for three years. When he was seventeen, Butler began his career with
Harbour View. During a tournament in
Guadeloupe,
L'Etoile spotted Butler and signed him to a contract when he was nineteen. In 1990, Butler entered
Southern New Hampshire University (then known as New Hampshire College) where he played with the men's soccer team from 1990 to 1993. He received
All-Americana recognition three times, twice as a first team (1992 and 1993). Butler graduated in 1994 with a
bachelor's degree in sociology and a minor in computer information. In 2001, he was inducted in the SNHU Penmen Hall of Fame. ==Professional career==