Vancouver Whitecaps, 2011 During the summer of 2011, Wisner played for the
Vancouver Whitecaps in the
W-League. She made five appearances, playing 391 minutes, and provided one assist.
Bayern Munich, 2013–2015 On January 11, 2013, Wisner signed with German club,
Bayern Munich in the
Bundesliga until June 30, 2014. In her first Bundesliga game against
SGS Essen, she scored two goals, including the game-winning goal in the 90th minute.
Portland Thorns, 2013–2014 Wisner was drafted by
Portland Thorns on January 18, 2013, during the
2013 National Women's Soccer League College Draft. Her debut came while visiting the
Houston Dash in which she played the entirety of the 1–0 victory. She would go on to start another 19 matches for the club in addition to a solitary substitution appearance. Wisner collected her first and only goal for the Thorns during the season while adding two assists, though her primary contributions were on the defensive end of the field where her ferocity led to a team-leading four yellow cards on the season. After the conclusion of the Thorns
2014 season, the team announced that she would be on loan to her previous side
Bayern Munich and become the second Portland member to be headed to Germany after the 2014 season, following teammate
Verónica Boquete to the
Bundesliga. While Portland initially indicated that Wisner would be re-signed for the
2015 National Women's Soccer League season, she was instead traded to the
Western New York Flash on November 6, 2014, in exchange for midfielder
McCall Zerboni and defender
Kathryn Williamson. She made twelve appearances and scored one goal for Seattle.
Houston Dash, 2015–2019 On October 26, 2015, Wisner was traded to the
Houston Dash in exchange for
Meghan Klingenberg and a conditional selection in the 2017
NWSL College Draft from
Seattle Reign. Wisner had her contract option exercised for the 2017 season. She was named the 2017 Dash
MVP and played all 2,160 minutes of the regular season, scored one goal and tallied two assists, captaining the side eight times. She was then re-signed for the 2018 season. Wisner was named 2018 Dash Defender of the Year. The club has exercised her contract option for the 2019 season. On April 14, 2019, Wisner played in her 100th career NWSL game, becoming the 22nd player to reach that mark.
Loan to Adelaide United in 2019 Wisner signed with
Adelaide United for the
2018–19 W-League season, alongside
Houston Dash teammate
Veronica Latsko.
OL Reign, 2020–2021 Wisner was out of contract following the
2019 NWSL season and
Houston Dash traded her rights to
OL Reign. She subsequently signed a three-year contract with the Tacoma-based club on March 4, 2020.
Washington Spirit, 2022–2023 Wisner signed one-year deal with the Washington Spirit in 2022. She would re-sign with the club for another year on December 19, 2022.
Dallas Trinity FC, 2024 in 2026 Wisner was the first player signed to
Dallas Trinity FC. She was named the team captain for Dallas's inaugural match against
Tampa Bay Sun FC on August 19, 2024. ==International career==