American Home Shield (AHS) has faced legal and regulatory scrutiny as well as a substantial volume of consumer complaints. In 2010, the State of Texas settled with AHS for approximately $5 million over allegations that the company engaged in "false, misleading or deceptive acts and practices," including routine denial of high-cost service claims; AHS made no admission of wrongdoing Inman. In addition, AHS reached a settlement in the
Abney v. American Home Shield class-action case concerning broker compensation under the
Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), where a federal court approved new broker compensation practices that purportedly complied with RESPA guidelines and released real estate professionals from any past liability investors.frontdoorhome.com. On the consumer front, the
Better Business Bureau (BBB) has received a significant number of complaints regarding AHS. The BBB reports tens of thousands of complaints over recent years—one source cites over 28,700 complaints overall, with common issues being unfulfilled repair commitments, poor communication, and dissatisfaction with subcontracted service quality Trusted Company Reviews. Other consumer reviews and watchdog sources note customer frustration with delays in claim approval, difficulty replacing covered items, and service fees without resolution == Products ==