For the franchise's 30th anniversary,
TV Guide ranked "Amok Time" No. 2 on its list of the 10 best
Star Trek episodes. In 2009, Zack Handlen of
The A.V. Club gave the episode an A rating. In 2012,
The A.V. Club ranked this episode as one of top ten "must see" episodes of the original series. In 2012,
The Christian Science Monitor ranked this the best episode of the original
Star Trek. In 2014,
Gizmodo ranked "Amok Time" as the 12th best episode of
Star Trek, out of the over 700 ones made by that time.
IGN ranked "Amok" number 9 in a top ten list of original series episodes. In 2015,
Wired magazine did not recommend skipping this episode in their binge-watching guide for the original series. In 2015,
Polygon ranked "Amok Time" as one of the three best Spock-centric episodes of
Star Trek. In 2015,
SyFy ranked this episode as one of the top ten essential
Star Trek original series episodes. In 2015,
New York Public Library cited this episode as having Spock's second best scene in the show. In 2016,
The Hollywood Reporter rated "Amok Time" the 28th best television episode of all
Star Trek franchise television prior to
Star Trek: Discovery, including live-action and the animated series but not counting the movies. In 2016,
Newsweek ranked "Amok Time" as one of the best episodes of the original series, noting it has one of the most memorable fights in
Star Trek. In 2016,
Business Insider ranked "Amok Time" the 10th best episode of the original series. In 2016,
Radio Times ranked the duel between Kirk and Spock on Vulcan as the 15th best moment in all
Star Trek. They note this shows the audience the Vulcan home planet of Vulcan for the first time, and also introduces the Pon Farr aspect of Vulcan culture. In 2018,
PopMatters ranked this the 10th best episode of the original series. They highlighted Spock's line "After a time, you may find that having is not so pleasing a thing after all as wanting. It is not logical, but it is often true." while noting the introduction of planet Vulcan, Pon Farr, various guest stars, and what they call a "thrilling gladiatorial battle". In 2019,
Nerdist included this episode on their "Best of Spock"
binge-watching guide. In 2019,
CBR ranked this episode as one of the top 8 most memorable episodes of the original
Star Trek. In 2024
Hollywood.com ranked Amok Time at number 7 out of the 79 original series episodes. ==Legacy==