Finley was the winner of the third season of
The Next Food Network Star. She originally attempted to remove herself from the competition following a disastrous five-minute cooking demonstration in Week 5, but was rebuffed by the judges. She was eliminated in Week 7, but after Josh "JAG" Garcia withdrew from the competition for lying about his culinary and military background, Amy was reinstated for the finale in his place, and she was voted the winner over runner-up Rory Schepisi making her the second female contestant to win in this show.
The Gourmet Next Door was named after the theme she adopted through the competition, demonstrating the ease of cooking like a gourmet chef at home. The show aired from October 14 to December 23, 2007, for a total of six episodes, after which it was quietly replaced in its timeslot with reruns of ''
Guy's Big Bite''. Following months of speculation, Finley revealed in May 2008 that she had voluntarily turned down the opportunity to return for a second season, citing the stress of the obligations of being a television personality. She resided in
Burgundy,
France, with her family before they returned to San Diego. In 2012, Finley appeared on an episode of
Chopped featuring past
Food Network Star winners
Aarti Sequeira,
Melissa d'Arabian, and
Jeff Mauro. She was eliminated after the second round. ==References==