Analysis of the My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic fandom

In 2012, two informal surveys involving 2,300 and 9,000 participants, respectively, revealed that the average age of adult fans was around 21, approximately 86% were male, and 63% were currently pursuing a college degree or higher qualification. The surveys estimated that there were between 7 and 12.4 million people in the United States who would identify themselves as bronies in January 2012. During the same period, a more detailed study called the Brony Study was conducted by Dr. Patrick Edwards, a psychology professor at Wofford College. Edwards had initially compiled one of the aforementioned informal surveys and presented the results at ongoing brony conventions, noting that the brony fandom provided "the opportunity to study a fan phenomenon from its inception" and planned to continue the survey to watch the evolution of the subculture. The 2012 edition of the Brony Study (with 1,300 respondents) found that 86% of bronies were male with an average age of 21; 84% identified as heterosexual, 10.3% as bisexual, 1.7% as homosexual, 3.8% as asexual; 62% were college students or graduates, and 35.2% were in high school; 70% were students, and 32.7% were employed; 69% were from North America, 22% from Europe, and 5% from Oceania; 96.4% were single and 2.9% were married. 2014 In September 2019, Edwards published the book Meet the Bronies, which summarized the results of the Brony Studies from 2012 to 2018. Across 19 surveys involving over 50,000 participants, bronies were found to be predominantly young adult males with an average age of 21 in 2012 and 26 in 2018, showing an upward trend over time as fans aged with the show. Approximately 86% of participants identified as male in early studies; later research revealed greater gender diversity, with 5.4% identifying as transgender and 3.6% as non-binary or genderqueer by 2016. The studies consistently found that around 70% of bronies identified as heterosexual, 10% as bisexual, 2% as homosexual, and 9% as asexual, making them approximately twice as likely to identify as LGBT compared to the general population of similar age. Female bronies were significantly more likely to identify as non-heterosexual than their male counterparts; 79.5% of male fans identified as heterosexual compared to only 47.9% of female fans. The majority of participants (62–63%) were pursuing college degrees or higher education, with 30–70% currently attending college and 40–60% enrolled as full-time students; 15–30% were working full-time, 20–25% part-time, and 18–20% were unemployed. Bronies were primarily from English-speaking countries and predominantly resided in larger cities with populations over 500,000. The studies also found that 94% were unmarried, though relationship patterns improved over time, with early studies showing many single participants but later surveys indicating the majority were in non-married dating relationships by 2016. Most bronies reported joining the fandom around the second and third seasons of the show; by 2016, bronies had an average of 3.7 years in the fandom. == Identification with the term brony ==

The term brony, a portmanteau of bro and pony, emerged in 2010 from 4chan as a reflection of the predominantly adult male fanbase of the show and became widely used as a gender-neutral identifier despite its masculine linguistic origins. The alternative term pegasister was created specifically for female fans, A 2017 ethnographic study of :/mlp/ (the My Little Pony board of 4chan) found that some adult male fans of the show who use /mlp/ explicitly rejected the brony label in favor of more transgressive, self-deprecating, and tongue-in-cheek labels like ponyfag and horsefucker. == Discrimination and anti-fandom ("anti-bronies") ==

In a 2021 analysis of brony discussions on Reddit, sociologist Steven Dashiell found that bronies experience stigma and discrimination due to graphic stereotypes portraying them as "disgusting weirdos who are sexually attracted to animals from a children's television show" or "some combination of gay, socially incompetent and perverted." Dashiell wrote that mainstream media has actively stigmatized the community, such as a 2011 Adult Swim ad that included bronies in their "all-time list of creepy weird things that scare [them]." Dashiell found that the potential for ridicule and discrimination leads many bronies to hide their identity in public spaces, only feeling comfortable expressing their fandom in designated safe spaces like brony conventions and online communities. The study also found that bronies are frequently mischaracterized as having sexual interests in the show's content and are often incorrectly grouped with furries. Bronies have received ridicule in other places, including Fox News and 4chan, with attacks on their gender, mental health, sexuality, and maturity being frequent. A subsequent 2018 study of over 3,500 participants from various fandoms found evidence of a psychological phenomenon called "denial of personal discrimination." When researchers asked fans two separate questions—whether their fandom as a group faces discrimination and whether they personally have experienced discrimination—participants consistently gave different answers. Fans acknowledged that their fandom faces discrimination but reported experiencing less discrimination themselves individually, a pattern that occurred across bronies, furries, anime fans, and general interest fan groups. == Psychology ==

The 2013 edition of the Brony Study found that bronies' initial reactions to Friendship Is Magic fell into two categories, with negative reactions being stronger than positive reactions, as represented by responses ranging from "I thought the idea that I might like MLP was strange and creepy" to "I thought it was cool and something I could be passionate about." The study identified two main behavioral patterns: a Social Factor characterized by high engagement and visibility, and an Isolation Factor marked by secrecy and withdrawal from the community. This led to a four-type classification: Social Bronies (37.5% of subjects) who were openly engaged with the community; Secret Bronies (12.6%) who were engaged but hidden from family and friends; Hidden Bronies (39.6%) who were both disengaged and secretive; and Independent Bronies (10.2%) who were open about their identity but not community-focused. == Participatory culture ==

, one of the most influential and acclaimed works of the My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic'' fan fiction community, has inspired a large amount of fan art. Academics have characterized the brony fandom as a participatory culture, where fans actively engage with the source material by creating their own content rather than simply consuming it. The fandom produces a large quantity of Internet memes, fan art, fan fiction, fan music, and fan animations. The brony fandom's strong participatory culture is credited for creating the character of Derpy Hooves, a background pony with crossed eyes from the first episode. == Hegemonic masculinity ==

The brony fandom has been studied as a major case study in hegemonic masculinity and its subversion. Military personnel '', posing for a group photo after the panel "Bronies in Uniform" at San Diego Comic-Con 2018 The brony fandom notably has a subculture of enlisted military personnel; studies have estimated that military bronies comprise 4–5% of the overall brony population. In the Journal of Fandom Studies, Maria Patrice Amon argued that military bronies challenge traditional ideas about masculinity because their military service gives them secure masculine credentials, which allows them to openly enjoy a show designed for young girls without losing their masculine identity. According to Amon, by expressing emotions and sensitivity—traits traditionally associated with women—while maintaining their roles as soldiers, military bronies expand what it means to be masculine in military culture. Sociologist Kevin W. Martin wrote in Pacific Standard that the military bronies phenomenon is "a fascinating site of negotiations of masculinity in one of its strongest bastions." He also observed that "male military bronies at times suffer from the kind of stigma and bullying reserved for feminine men and, because they are also often assumed to be gay, homophobia." == Parasociality ==

In 2015, Anne Gilbert wrote in Transformative Works and Cultures that bronies form strong emotional connections with the Mane Six (the six main characters of Friendship Is Magic), often identifying with specific characters and appreciating their detailed personalities and growth arcs. Gilbert observed that bronies praise the characters' complexity and development, with fans expressing sentiments like "I've practically fallen in love with Twilight... she's socially awkward as well and to see her grow and make friends, it makes me happy." However, Gilbert argued that bronies' engagement with the characters occurs within a framework that maintains traditional masculine identity. Rather than embracing the characters' originally intended feminist messaging, Gilbert observed that bronies tend to appropriate the Mane Six by emphasizing their similarities to traditionally masculine geek culture references, effectively incorporating their appreciation for these female characters into conventional gender performances rather than allowing the characters to challenge existing notions of masculinity. In Meet the Bronies, Edwards examined preferences of the Mane Six and their psychological and parasocial relationships with bronies. They found that fans of different characters exhibited distinct psychological profiles that often mirrored their chosen character's canonical personality traits, with characters serving various parasocial functions from aspirational role models to sources of emotional support. Edwards's study showed correlations between character preference and traits like creativity, social anxiety, community engagement, and psychological well-being. == Religion and spirituality ==

Academics have documented the relationship between religious faith and the brony fandom. According to Edwards, bronies attend church less frequently than their parents and rate themselves below average on religiosity scales, possibly because mainstream religions often promote traditional gender norms that conflict with male fans enjoying a show marketed to girls. Edwards suggested that less religious bronies may be drawn to the fandom because it provides the sense of meaning and community that religious institutions typically offer, though he also remarked that bronies' lower religiosity levels are typical for their generations (millennials and Generation Z). Crome's 2014 research on Christian My Little Pony fan works found that rather than seeing fandom and faith as conflicting, many Christian bronies actively combined both. By studying their fan fiction and artwork, Crome documented how Christian bronies used familiar character traits to explain religious ideas, as the show's ostensible lack of religion provided "a space for fans to freely project religious concepts." In 2019, Crome interviewed twelve Christian bronies and remarked that the brony fandom served as a way for them to better experience religion. Interviewees reported organizing My Little Pony-themed church services, Bible studies, and using fan works to spread Christianity within the general brony fandom. Crome found that Christian bronies saw their fandom as a way God worked in their lives; they considered fan works to be forms of worship and their fandom to be a divine mission to spread Christianity within it. In his 2024 essay The Bible and My Little Pony, theology professor Tom de Bruin extended Crome's research on Christian My Little Pony fan fiction. De Bruin analyzed two primary methods bronies use to combine Christianity and My Little Pony: introducing ponies into biblical narratives, and introducing Christianity into Equestria. De Bruin found that while Christian bronies are respectful about religion and try to stick to correct religious beliefs, creating these works changes how they read the Bible, with readers reporting that biblical passages now remind them of My Little Pony characters. De Bruin borrowed Henry Jenkins's terminology to describe this fan activity as poaching: Christian bronies often read Christian meanings into the show even when the creators did not intend them, and develop personal fan theories that characters are Christians based on details like rainbow symbolism and phrases spoken by the characters like "my prayers have been answered." According to de Bruin, "[Christian My Little Pony fan fiction writers] are not simply using MLP fandom as a tool for theological reflection or religious experience, but also recasting the entire fandom into the worldview of their faith." He concluded that "their theology needs to be dogmatically correct, otherwise their engagement with the fandom will be for naught." In a 2016 essay on the spirituality of the brony fandom, Pavol Kosnáč separated casual fans from what he called "devotees": bronies whose entire lifestyle and beliefs are shaped by the show. Through interviews with 32 bronies and surveys with 99 others, he found that 63% said the show and its fandom had changed their worldview or moral values, and 12.5% called it the most important thing in their lives. Kosnáč identified several effects the show had on devoted bronies: a lasting sense of happiness that some said helped with depression, moral guidance from the show's lessons, and feeling safe in what they saw as a harsh world. Kosnáč found that for some Christian bronies, the show strengthened their existing faith. Like Edwards, Kosnáč concluded that the most devoted bronies treat the fandom like a religion because it provides psychological and social support like what organized religions typically offer. == New sincerity ==

in 2018 Though the initial growth of the fandom came from 4chan participants enjoying the ironic nature of grown men enjoying a show for girls, the fandom continued to grow based on sincere appreciation of the work. Robert Thompson, a professor of media studies at Syracuse University, stated that "It's one thing for guys to like motorcycles and muscle cars and soccer. For a guy to like My Little Pony, it's so out there that it becomes almost avant garde. It has a hip quality to it." According to Angela Watercutter of Wired, the fandom is an example of internet neo-sincerity, where these older viewers watch the show "un-ironically" and "without guilt" breaking gender stereotypes, furthermore creating new material around it. Prof. Roberta Pearson of the University of Nottingham in film and television studies stated that "This is a level of fan devotion I've not seen before", while Prof. Charles Soukup of the University of Northern Colorado in communication studies suggested that this effort is an indication of the "ultra-cult era" that bronies exhibit, where "media consumers discover extremely unexpected and obscure media texts to cultivate uniqueness and distinctiveness for their mediated identities". Jessica Klein, writing for Salon, noted that the fandom was an especially welcoming space for female fans in comparison to other male-dominated fandoms. == Overlap with the furry fandom ==

2019 that reads "bronies are diet furries", a reference to the similarities between the brony and furry fandoms The brony fandom is distinct from the furry fandom. However, research has documented overlap between the two fandoms. Longitudinal studies of the furry fandom found that in 2012, approximately 25% of furries identified as bronies; the show's popularity impacted furry fandom content creation, with many furry artists producing My Little Pony fan art during the show's early years. The percentage of furries who were also bronies gradually declined to 15% by 2019 and stabilized at around 10% as of 2023. Contrary to perceptions of bronies as outsiders "invading" the furry fandom, studies found that furries who identify as bronies have on average been involved in the furry fandom longer than non-brony furries. Compared to non-brony furries, brony furries reported smaller friendship networks, but demonstrated greater involvement in furry fandom activities, including higher attendance at in-person events and stronger feelings of community belonging. Brony furries tend to be more obsessive over the furry fandom than non-brony furries and were more likely to openly disclose their involvement in the furry fandom. Brony furries scored lower on perspective-taking but reported greater feelings of solidarity with animals, stronger spiritual connections to their fursona species, and were more likely to endorse New Age beliefs and identify as spiritual. In general, furry bronies did not experience stigmatization within the brony fandom for their participation in the furry fandom. == See also ==