In 1914, Anders Randolf began appearing in 1- or 2-reelers with the
Vitagraph Studios stock company, and earned critical praise in his first feature film
The Wheels of Justice (1915) in the role of Tug' Riley, a convict. A reviewer in the
New York Dramatic Mirror wrote: "Anders Randolf as Tug Riley is undoubtedly the most real in the excellent cast." Randolf continued working with Vitagraph until 1919 even as the production company's fortunes declined. The company was acquired by Warner Bros. studios in 1925. As a freelance performer, Rudolf was provided with "top supporting roles" in high production features. He worked for
Cosmopolitan productions, co-starring with
Marion Davies in
The Cinema Murder (1919),
Buried Treasure (1921), and
Enchantment. Regarded as "one of Hollywood's most respected heavies", he was often cast to play villains. A versatile actor, Randolf could expertly play comedic roles, for example, as a incompetent banker in
In Hollywood with Potash and Perlmutter (1923); and
Mary Pickford's father in
Dorothy Vernon of Haddon Hall (1924). At the pinnacle of his career, the 50-year-old Randolf was cast as the pirate captain in
The Black Pirate (1924), a swashbuckler starring
Douglas Fairbanks. His outstanding skills as a swordsman were on display in the final duel sequence. Critic
Mordaunt Hall in the
New York Times congratulated Randolf on his "cunning and brutal" interpretation of the role. ==Late career and death==