Atherton's heady rise continued when he made his debut for England in the fifth test of 1989 against
Australia at
Trent Bridge, where he scored 0 and 47. Atherton's chance came when several England players announced their decision to go on a
rebel tour to South Africa and so were banned from the Test team. Despite these defections, he was selected as vice-captain of the 1989–90 A-team tour to
Zimbabwe rather than for the
West Indies tour. He learned that he would make his debut when captain
David Gower threw a plastic bag of England caps and sweaters at him. Atherton returned to the England side in the summer of 1990, partnering
Graham Gooch at the top of the order and giving the first demonstration of his abilities at international level. In his first innings after recall, and his first opening the batting for England, he scored 151 against
New Zealand. He shared an opening partnership of 204 with Gooch against
India at Lord's, in the match famous for Gooch's scores of 333 and 123, as well as further big opening partnerships in the next two Tests, and Test centuries against
New Zealand and India earned him the title of Young Cricketer of the Year. During the winter of 1990–91, Atherton faced a sterner test on
the Ashes tour of Australia. Although he made a century in the third Test at
Sydney, which would prove to be his only century in an Ashes Test, he averaged just 31 for his 279 runs, and
England lost 3–0. Atherton struggled against
the West Indies in 1991 and missed the
1992 Cricket World Cup and
tour of New Zealand with fitness problems, but was recalled to the Test team in the summer of 1992. When Australia arrived for the
1993 Ashes series, Atherton's place in the team was not assured. However, a consistent summer, during which he scored six 50s in six Tests (including 99 at
Lord's), cemented his place in the side at a fortunate time. Graham Gooch, frustrated by continual losses against Australia, resigned as captain after the fourth Test and Atherton, aged just 25, replaced him. He lost his first match in charge but England managed to beat Australia in a morale-boosting final Test; England had not beaten Australia in the previous 18 Test matches. Atherton's first tour as captain, to the
West Indies in
the winter of 1993–94, was not a success as England lost 3–1. This was a series of highs and lows:
Brian Lara of the West Indies compiled a world-record 375 against them at
Antigua; England were bowled out for 46 to lose the third Test (and with it the series) but then roared back at
Bridgetown to win the fourth Test thanks to two centuries from
Alec Stewart. For his part, Atherton was the best of the English batsmen, scoring 510 runs at an average of 56.67. Earning plaudits for his determination and leadership, Atherton followed up with two centuries in the
three-match series at home against New Zealand. His reputation suffered a blow when he was implicated in a
ball-tampering controversy during the first Test against South Africa at Lord's, for which he was fined £2,000 by
Ray Illingworth. Atherton was accused of lying to
Peter Burge, the match referee. Atherton claims in his autobiography that he answered "no" when asked if he had anything in his pockets. He believed that Burge was referring to nefarious substances such as resin or lip salve. Nonetheless the TV pictures were damning, showing Atherton deliberately putting dirt, taken from the pitch, on the ball. Strictly speaking, Atherton was not breaking the
laws – he pointed out that plenty of bowlers improve their grip on the ball by rubbing their hands on the pitch. After this incident Atherton and England headed to
Headingley for the second Test. Atherton played one of his best innings, grinding out 99 before being caught and bowled by
Brian McMillan. Atherton stated that this innings was the best answer he could have given to the "gutter press". He led England to a win in the third Test at
the Oval, which tied the series, although he failed to score a century. After winning against South Africa, Atherton faced the supreme test of his leadership:
an Ashes tour to Australia. His form stood well, with 407 runs at 40.7, but he was unable to convert any of his four half-centuries in the Test series into a hundred. Although England had a thrilling win at
Adelaide, England's first Test victory in Australia for eight years, the team stumbled to a 1–3 loss. There was also controversy in the drawn
Sydney test when England's
Graeme Hick was approaching what would have been his only
Ashes Test hundred. According to
Wisden: "In what was thought to be the last-but-one over of the innings, Hick, on 98, blocked three successive balls, and Atherton lost patience and ungenerously declared; he had batted far more slowly himself". The next two years followed a similar pattern. Although a draw in
a Test series against the West Indies in 1995 and victory in Test series at home against
India and away against
New Zealand suggested that England were improving, the team continued to struggle against the talent of Australia and
Pakistan. Although Atherton led England to victory in the first test of the
1997 Ashes at
Birmingham, England's only victory in an Ashes Test that was not a
dead rubber between 1986 and 2005, England lost the series 3-2. England also crashed out of the
1996 Cricket World Cup after defeat to eventual champions
Sri Lanka, controversy also ensuing during this tournament after a defeat when Atherton's irritated observation about a local journalist was picked up on tape. The lack of consistent progress and the effect of a back ailment contributed to Atherton's decision to resign after five years as
captain after
a defeat in the West Indies in 1997-8. Atherton continued to play Test cricket for a further four years before retiring at the end of the
2001 Ashes. However, plagued by his chronic back condition, he did not manage to attain his previous levels of performance. Highlights of his later career however included
man of the match-winning Test centuries at
the Oval and
Karachi in 2000, in Tests which ensured England rare Test series victories respectively against the West Indies (their first for 31 years), and Pakistan (their first for 18 years). Atherton's finest performances came when he had his back against the wall. Notable examples include his monumental 185 not out in 643 minutes to salvage a draw against South Africa, and his negation of an outstanding
Allan Donald onslaught in 1998. This doggedness prompted
Steve Waugh to dub him "The Cockroach", but his record against Australia was modest. He averaged under thirty, with only one century in 33 tests. and he was dismissed 19 times by
Glenn McGrath, the Australian opening bowler, a record for any bowler against one batsman. Alongside McGrath, two other world-class bowlers frequently tormented Atherton, with Courtney Walsh dismissing him seventeen times and Shane Warne ten times. As well as being seen as struggling against the very best, Atherton had the dubious honour of having the lowest batting average of any player to have scored 6,000 or more runs in
Test cricket at the time of his retirement. He was also dismissed for nought on twenty occasions at Test level, which was an English record at the time of his retirement.{{cite web|url=http://stats.espncricinfo.com/wi/content/records/283087.html|publisher=ESPNcricinfo|title=Most Ducks in a Career
International centuries During his career Atherton made eighteen
centuries in international cricket, sixteen of which were scored in Test matches while the other two came in One Day Internationals. In Tests, thirteen of his centuries came in the first innings and three in the second innings. ==Post-playing career==