The mental, physical, and financial abuse Cohen perpetrated against former students, which he justifies as "crazy wisdom", are documented in books such as
American Guru,
Enlightenment Blues, and
Mother of God, as well as popular blogs such as
What Enlightenment? and
EnlightenNixt.
H. W. L. Poonja, also known as Papaji, the Indian guru who Cohen claimed called him his "heir", stated publicly that Cohen only spent 25 hours in satsang before proclaiming himself as enlightened. Papaji describes Cohen's claims as the arrogance of his ego and never acknowledged Cohen as a master or heir, but rather described him as a messenger. Poonja himself has been sharply criticized for too easily authorising students to teach: Some of Cohen's former followers, including his mother, Luna Tarlo, have viewed him as a manipulative spiritual teacher. Tarlo wrote a critical book, called
Mother of God, about her experience as one of his disciples. In a
Psychology Today article published in 1998, entitled "Crimes of the Soul", Tarlo recounted how she became a disciple of her son who told her "to give way to him or their relationship would end" and forbade her "to express an opinion on anything". Tarlo said she "knew if I seriously objected to anything, I'd be kicked out" and stated that her son, formerly the "sweetest, sensitive kid, had changed into an unrecognizable tyrant". André van der Braak's
Enlightenment Blues: My Years with an American Guru alleges that Cohen demanded large sums of money and extreme and unquestioning devotion from his students.
American Guru: A Story of Love, Betrayal and Healing, by William Yenner and other former Cohen student contributors (foreword by
Stephen Batchelor), allege authoritarianism, financial manipulation, physical, and psychological abuse in Cohen's community, and discusses the challenges of healing after leaving the community. According to Christopher Titmuss, Cohen was haunted by "the idealism, perfectionism and pressures [...] that an enlightened life should be a state of perfection", As of early 2014, the EnlightenNext organization's main building on its property in Lenox, Massachusetts, which had been on the market for years, remained up for sale. In 2016, over 240 of Cohen's former students signed an
online petition titled "Stop Andrew Cohen teaching again", including detailed explanations of why they believe him to be unfit to teach others. ==Works==