Andrews High School was incorporated on March 3, 1893, by the
North Carolina General Assembly. The school had already been in existence before this date. Andrews High School originally started as a private school and operated that way until around 1915. Andrews High School was built in 1914 and opened in 1915. The building was a three-story facility. The school had parts that the current facility lacks today, such as an auditorium. The building was located on the property of Andrews Elementary on what is locally known as "School House Hill". All of the Andrews schools were located on this hill until 1962. Andrews fielded its first football team in fall 1929. The team's 50 year anniversary was celebrated October 19, 1979, with original players attending the homecoming game. In 1952, the first edition of AHS's yearbook,
The Wildcat was published. On Feb. 20, 1962, the two-story brick school building was destroyed by fire overnight. Classes were then held in the town's Baptist and Methodist churches. A new 48,000-square-foot high school building saw one wing open in the spring of 1963 and another wing open later that year. Chivous Gilmer Harrill was the architect for the building. Harrill also designed the
Murphy High School campus. The old building's bell is across the street at Andrews Elementary, in the middle of the front driveway loop. In 1970, the Andrews Junior High School building was constructed south of the cafeteria and gymnasium building. This was the first expansion to the current high school campus. In 1973, the school's band program was founded. Miss Mary Byrd, the first director, spent two years organizing the initial Junior High School Band (for grades 7–10), in preparation for expansion into the eleventh and twelfth grades. In 1975, a large mountain cat was stuffed by a taxidermist to become the mascot for the Andrews Wildcats. The band purchased their first uniforms in 1975. In 1977, the band participated in the inauguration of governor
Jim Hunt. Today, the band is known as the '''Pride of the Valley' Band''. The Hugh Hamilton Stadium was built in 1976. The stadium consisted of two sets of wooden stands on the east and west side, two concession booths (one for athletics and one for the band booster program), a ticket stand, and a press box. The wooden stands were updated to concrete in 1980. Around 1978, the enrollment at Andrews Senior and Junior High was about 600, and the enrollment at the nearby elementary school was of about 800, totaling about 1400. Andrews had a percentage of 64% of graduates who move into higher education, compared to the state average of that time of 30%. 98.6% of that 64% received scholarships or financial aid through the efforts student counselors. In 1978, Andrews was number 3 in the state of North Carolina of scholarship money awarded. Andrews was the top school in North Carolina for placement in summer jobs in 1979. Andrews had up to 8 sports around 1979, which was very high over the usual 2 or 3 sports for a school of its size. Band, art, and chorus were offered at Andrews High School, which was not usually found in schools of small enrollments. Band and art are still offered as electives today. An on-campus masters program was offered at Andrews with the help of
Western Carolina University. From 1964 until around 1992, graduations were held in the Ken Solesbee Athletic Center. From 1992 onward, graduations have still been held in the Athletic Center, but primarily in Hugh Hamilton Stadium, depending on weather conditions. In response to the
COVID-19 pandemic, Andrews High School did not have a graduation for seniors in the class of 2020. Instead, with Covid relief funding, pictures of the graduates were put up on utility poles in the town from just east of the intersection of Main Street and US-19, to the intersection of Main Street and Wilson Street. This began a new tradition of graduates' portraits and names being put up on each of the 18 poles from the area (most have two on a pole while others have three or four). The banner tradition was originally discontinued for the 2025 school year, citing no more funding for the banners, but only a few hours later, it was announced that the banners would go up with funding from an anonymous donor. In 1975, a state study strongly recommended consolidating Andrews and Murphy high schools. In May 2020, the Cherokee County Board of Education voted to consolidate Andrews,
Murphy, and
Hiwassee Dam High Schools. The state awarded a $50 million grant to build a new central high school in
Peachtree, but after public outcry newly elected school board members voted to return the money and maintain the status quo. In October 2025, following the resignation of principal Sheryl Rogers, Ruby Cutshaw & Thomas Graham served as co-interim principals, with Cutshaw serving on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, and Graham on Tuesday and Thursday. This was an uncommon practice at Cherokee County Schools. It was later announced that Dorin Oxender would serve as the new principal of Andrews High. ==Athletics==