In 1973, the album was ranked No. 3 on Dutch Muziekkrant OOR's list of best albums of 1973. And
Al Kooper listed the album at No. 58 on his list of
100 Greatest Recordings of All Time. The album has consistently been praised by critics. Reviewing the album in his consumer guide for
The Village Voice,
Robert Christgau gave the album a C and highly praised the track "Avenging Annie" commenting that it "is an astounding tale of feminist revenge in the twilight of the counterculture." but didn't comment on any of the other tracks on the album. In a retrospective review for AllMusic, critic Michael Ofjord gave the album four and a half out of five stars and wrote that "Andy Pratt's self-titled album is a very quirky, idiosyncratic album that definitely establishes Pratt as a major force in the singer-songwriter arena." while also praising "Avenging Annie" commenting that "The fast piano technique is impressive, as are some other production touches (such as the cat sounds and descending guitar line). The song deserves its classic status hands down." ==Track listing==