Larry Flick of
Billboard magazine wrote: "Follow-up to debut U.S. single 'Metal Mickey' not as hard-hitting, but a strong cut no less. Sound is skewed toward
power pop, with emphasis on heavy melody and stomping rhythms. Perhaps too much emphasis on the latter, however, as single lacks fluidity. Much-touted lead singer Brett Anderson wrenches his vocals from the gut, recalling early performances from
Duran Duran's
Simon LeBon." Richard Plunkett of
The Age awarded it 'Single of the Week', writing: "This single is their album's strongest, an irresistible mix of strange guitar riffery, manic rhythm section and a personality desperately craving to be noticed." Martin Aston of
Music Week said the song "has a wonderfully addictive chorus" and "plenty of glam-pop charm." Previewing the band’s 27 March show at Dublin’s Tivoli Theatre, Tony Clayton-Lea of the
Sunday Tribune called it "a cracker of a song." Tony Cross of
Smash Hits was more mixed, calling it a "simply 'OK'" song. He wrote: "Brett's ever so English (and ever so affected) vocals judder through sometimes awkward guitars in what ends up as, at times, just a jittery and sinister racket."
Select ranked the song at No. 1 in its singles of the year for 1993. In March 2005,
Q placed "Animal Nitrate" at No. 97 in its list of the 100 Greatest Guitar Tracks. In May 2007,
NME magazine placed "Animal Nitrate" at No. 43 in its list of the 50 Greatest Indie Anthems Ever. In 2012 the same magazine placed the song at No. 14 on its 100 Best Tracks of the Nineties. It again recognised the song in 2014 by ranking it at No. 33 in its list of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time. A 2010
Radio X poll of listeners, presenters and a team of experts compiled a list of the top 1000 songs of all time, where "Animal Nitrate" ranked at No. 60. In 2014,
Paste listed the song at No. 29 in its 50 Best Britpop Songs. Caroline Sullivan of
The Guardian included the song in her "10 of the Best" Britpop songs. She said that "Butler's opening riff is one of the most undeniable in pop."
Classic Rock included Butler's guitar solo at No. 94 in their list of the "100 greatest guitar solos in rock." Paul Nolan of
Hot Press called the song "one of the greatest singles of the ’90s," in a review of the band's first night performance of their eponymous album at the 2011 three-night residency at the Dublin Olympia Theatre. ==Music video==